# City Council Meeting – October 9, 2018

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** October 9, 2018 11:00 AM EDT (2018-10-09T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5319/city-council-meeting-october-9-2018
**Outcome:** Council denied the Maxwell Street short-term rental rezoning and approved the Brevard Road hotel with conditions.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on October 9, 2018, to address a variety of agenda items, including routine consent matters, public hearings on zoning and road closures, and updates on city programs. The meeting began with a proclamation honoring the late civic leader, legislator, and diplomat Mary Jacqueline Waters Colton, which the council adopted. The council also approved the consent agenda, which included support for a tactical urbanism project on Cox Avenue and the establishment of a Vision Zero Task Force.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The council adopted resolutions to permanently close two unopened rights-of-way: Smathers Lane and an unnamed road near the intersection of Hendersonville Road and Sweeten Creek Road. In a significant zoning decision, the council voted to deny a request to rezone properties at 28 and 32 Maxwell Street from residential to lodging expansion for short-term rentals. The motion to deny cited that the use is not permitted in surrounding districts, there is insufficient space for required buffering and parking, street parking is reserved for long-term residents, and the change does not benefit the public generally. No final vote tally was recorded for this item. Conversely, the council approved the conditional zoning request for the Main State Suites Hotel at 511 Brevard Road via a hand vote. Council Member Julie Mayfield stated she would vote "no," but no specific numerical tally or other dissenting votes were recorded. Approval includes conditions such as sidewalks, a transit shelter, a pedestrian crossing signal, no drive-throughs on the out-parcel, shuttle service to downtown, the airport, and the Asheville Outlets, and a commitment to contribute $150,000 to the Asheville-Buncombe Land Trust. Additionally, the council appointed Carter Webb to the Civil Service Board with no opposition recorded.

**Discussion Highlights**
The Maxwell Street zoning hearing generated significant debate regarding the impact of the adjacent Green Life grocery store (now Whole Foods) on the neighborhood. Council Member Haynes stated he would support the applicant, arguing it was a "special case" and not a precedent, noting that the street felt commercial due to unenforced violations. Council Member Mayfield apologized for the city’s inaction over the last 15 years but stated she was troubled by the proposal because short-term rentals do not solve the underlying problem of the loading dock and truck traffic. She emphasized that the issue was the commercial entity, not the residents. Regarding the hotel zoning at 511 Brevard Road, Council Member Mayfield argued that the area needs multifamily housing rather than another hotel. The Mayor expressed concern that six hotels are in the pipeline and noted that while the city collects around $64 million in property tax revenue, hotels contribute only $3.25 million, meaning taxpayers are subsidizing infrastructure for tourism. Another council member stated he would vote with Mayfield, emphasizing the need for economic diversity beyond tourism.

**Community Input**
Public commenters at the Maxwell Street hearing raised concerns about 15 years of unenforced violations by the adjacent grocery store, including truck noise and loading dock issues. One commenter warned of potential federal lawsuits regarding equal protection and due process if the city’s enforcement practices were challenged. At the hotel hearing, an applicant attorney stated the applicant has made commitments to provide a living wage and to contribute at least $150,000 to the land trust for affordable housing. During non-agenda public comment, a resident expressed concern about kudzu overgrowth on the Reed Creek Greenway, proposing livestock grazing as a solution. The Mayor suggested the commenter contact the Parks and Rec Board and City Manager Kathy Ball to determine if this approach had been considered. Another commenter warned the council to be cautious about anticipating a tax revenue windfall from the HCA acquisition of Mission Healthcare, citing a precedent in Silver where a hospital corporation challenged its assessment, resulting in a 70% reduction and a tax rate increase for residents. Members did not respond to this comment. A third commenter stated that the hotel tax is contributing to the displacement of the African American population in Asheville and criticized the lack of diversity on the Tourism Development Authority board. Members did not respond to this comment.

**Follow-ups**
Staff confirmed that the City Manager will form the Vision Zero Task Force based on staff recommendations, as the resolution is open-ended regarding membership criteria. Council Member Mayfield committed to pulling landlords into conversations with Whole Foods to put pressure on the commercial entity to resolve the loading dock and traffic issues permanently. The Mayor asked staff to provide the public commenter regarding the greenway with information about the Parks and Rec Board and to have them touch base with City Manager Kathy Ball regarding the status of kudzu management. Staff indicated that if the hotel zoning is approved, the final conditions will come back on the consent agenda. Staff and the applicant agreed to ask the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) to approve a pedestrian crossing signal on Brevard Road, in addition to the one on South Bear Creek Road. The applicant agreed to provide a right-of-way easement if needed for this crossing.

**Impact**
These decisions reflect the council's balancing of development requests with neighborhood stability and infrastructure needs. The denial of the Maxwell Street short-term rental request signals a stance against rezoning residential areas for lodging when adjacent commercial issues remain unresolved, while the approval of the Brevard Road hotel, despite dissent, indicates a willingness to proceed with tourism infrastructure under specific conditions. The public comments highlight ongoing tensions regarding the impact of large commercial entities on residential neighborhoods and the economic implications of tourism-focused development on local tax bases and demographics.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EBG415dKag
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3242/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EBG415dKag)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
