# City Council Work Session – August 28, 2018

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** August 28, 2018 11:00 AM EDT (2018-08-28T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5324/city-council-work-session-august-28-2018
**Outcome:** Council held an informational budget work session to review the $124 million general fund and departmental budgets, with no votes taken.

## Summary

The City of Asheville City Council held its first budget work session for the upcoming fiscal year on August 28, 2018. The meeting was strictly informational, designed to initiate the budget process early to facilitate greater community participation. No motions were made, no votes were taken, and no formal public comments were accepted during the session. The Chair noted that the City accepts emails for questions and committed to structuring a public engagement piece for subsequent steps in the process.

**Key Discussions: Community Profile and General Fund**
Presentations highlighted significant economic and demographic challenges facing the city. The cost of living is higher than most North Carolina cities, while the median household income is $45,000, below the national average of $55,000. Housing and transportation costs consume 55% of the average household income, exceeding the sustainable benchmark of 45%. CFO Barbara Whitehurst highlighted this affordability imbalance, stating, "Asheville comes in at 55%. If you combine the cost of housing and transportation... 45% is sort of a sustainable household... And we're at 55 on average. So it clearly, we're a little out of balance there."

Regarding the $124 million general fund budget, approximately 80% of revenue is derived from property taxes, sales taxes, and state utility taxes. Property tax is the only major locally controlled revenue source, with a current rate of 42.89 cents. A one-penny increase would generate approximately $1.5 million in additional revenue. On the expenditure side, personnel costs (salaries, wages, and benefits) account for roughly $77 million, with health insurance being the largest benefit cost at $9.5 million. Public safety, specifically police and fire services, consumes approximately 43% of the general fund budget. The city maintains an unassigned fund balance between 15% and 20% and holds a AAA bond rating from Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s.

**Departmental Budgets and Q&A**
The session included presentations on specific departmental budgets. The combined budget for the City Council, Manager, Clerk, and Attorney is approximately $2.9 million, with a primary challenge being the dramatic increase in public records requests, of which the Police Department accounts for roughly 60%. The Office of Sustainability’s budget is project-heavy, with 73% allocated to operating and projects rather than personnel. The Green Revolving Fund, funded by LED streetlight savings, is expected to have approximately $1.3 million available for projects in the current year. The Office of Equity and Inclusion is expanding from 1 to 4 Full-Time Equivalents (FTEs) in the current fiscal year to implement the Equity Action Plan and support the Human Relations Commission. Director of Equity and Inclusion Kimberly Archie justified the staff expansion, stating, "We are personnel driven and I like to say that we're growing our staff to make sure that we can grow our impact."

During the Q&A portion, a council member inquired about the calculation method for unemployment, specifically regarding individuals whose benefits expire. The CFO committed to researching this and posting the answer with the slides. The Budget Manager confirmed that non-profits do not pay property tax, noting the city receives a small Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILOT) from the Asheville Housing Authority (approx. $50,000–$60,000/year) and a state payment for fire protection to UNCA, but no other significant PILOTs exist. Concerns were raised that the Office of Sustainability is at staff capacity and may lack resources to implement a proposed 100% renewable energy resolution. A council member urged resource allocation for sustainability, stating, "If this continues to be a priority for the city... we really need to be thinking about getting the office [Sustainability] some more resources not just for the projects... but in terms of the staff to get it done." The Director acknowledged the challenge of balancing projects with current staffing levels.

**Notable Statements and Follow-ups**
City Manager Kathy Ball emphasized the long-term perspective of budgeting, stating, "I think I've talked to some of you I think all of us want to look back in 10 years and feel like we know and understand where that many money went and How it made a difference in our community as opposed to feeling like we've spent a little here and there." This comment referred to the potential impact of the Mission HCA sale. Budget Manager Tony McDowell contextualized personnel costs, noting, "We're a service organization, and so as a service organization, we employ a lot of people. And so a large portion of our budget is people-related in salary and benefits."

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the session:
*   **CFO Barbara Whitehurst** agreed to research the specific methodology for calculating unemployment statistics (specifically regarding those whose benefits expire) and post the answer with the presentation slides.
*   **Budget Manager Tony McDowell** agreed to correct a typo in the presentation slides regarding the valuation figure (14.6 million vs. 14.6 billion) and ensure the end slide is fixed.
*   **City Manager Kathy Ball** agreed to include the Council’s pre-meeting questions and the staff’s written responses as a supplemental memo on the Budget Work Sessions website.
*   **Staff** agreed to include a breakdown of partnership agreements (including dollar amounts and expiration dates) in future departmental budget presentations.

**Impact on Residents**
This work session provided foundational context for the upcoming fiscal year’s budget, highlighting the tension between rising costs of living and stagnant median incomes. The detailed breakdown of revenue sources and expenditure priorities, particularly the heavy reliance on personnel and public safety costs, offers residents insight into where tax dollars are allocated. The commitment to structured public engagement in the next steps of the budget process indicates that further opportunities for community input will be provided as the budget is developed.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkHpeBjUHOU
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3067/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkHpeBjUHOU)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
