# City Council Worksession – March 20, 2018

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 20, 2018 11:00 AM EDT (2018-03-20T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5330/city-council-worksession-march-20-2018
**Outcome:** Council replaced the City Manager, approved a third-party police review, and adopted new tennis center fees.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held a worksession on March 20, 2018, focusing on two primary areas: policing and public safety priorities, and the Fiscal Year 2018-19 budget. The meeting addressed significant personnel changes, proposed reforms to law enforcement oversight, and the city’s financial outlook, which includes a structural gap between revenue and expenditure growth.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The council made several unanimous decisions during the session. Most notably, the council voted to replace City Manager Gary Jackson effective immediately, with Assistant City Manager Kathy Ball serving as interim City Manager. The council confirmed that the city will honor the contractual obligation to pay Mr. Jackson’s salary and benefits for 180 days following his removal. Additionally, the council unanimously approved motions to conduct a third-party review of the Asheville Police Department (APD), explore funding an outside legal position to advocate for individuals filing complaints against law enforcement, and request specific changes from the state legislature. The council also voted to adopt new fees for the Aston Park Tennis Center for the 2018-19 season, including a change to the "senior" age threshold from 67 to 65. Finally, the council voted to enter a closed session to consult with an attorney regarding the *Bok v. City of Asheville* lawsuit before adjourning the open session.

**Policing and Public Safety Discussions**
A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to implementing recommendations from the Blue Ribbon Task Force. Councilwoman Gwen Whistler will lead transition planning pro bono. The council discussed the creation of a Human Relations Commission (HRC); the ordinance has been drafted and is expected to come to council for a vote on April 10. Staff will work with the Chief of Police to develop a proposal for the third-party APD review, specifically regarding the incident involving Mr. Rush and former officer Hickman, independent of the ongoing Department of Justice investigation.

The council also explored legal barriers to viewing body camera footage, noting that state law currently restricts this to sworn officers. Staff will look into the legality of assigning a non-sworn staff member in the Equity and Inclusion department to review footage. To assist residents, the council voted to explore funding an outside legal position, potentially at a non-profit like Pisgah Legal Services, to help individuals navigate the complaint process. Furthermore, the council voted to ask staff to review city personnel policies and Civil Service Board rules to allow for the timely removal of employees who demonstrate terminable conduct, while balancing employee protections. A council member stated, "We're trying to find that space of protecting employees so that they're not being unfairly disciplined or terminated... but also making sure that the management group can take definitive action in a timely manner to protect the interests of our citizens."

**Budget Presentation**
Finance Director Barbara Weidhorn presented the budget forecast, highlighting a structural imbalance where expenditures are growing faster than revenues. She noted, "We have the 2013 white paper that talks about the structure gap... which is basically that projected revenues are not increasing at the same rate as expenditures... We're in kind of a constant catch-up cycle." The presentation outlined projected revenue growth of approximately $2 million against projected expenditure increases of approximately $7.821 million, creating a gap of about $5.8 million. Staff identified $2.7 million in savings, reducing the remaining gap to $3.2 million. Weidhorn explained, "3.2 million is a pretty big goal... But the reality is for the city budget as a whole... it's a relatively small amount. It's just our hurdle this year is the 3.2 million." The city’s fund balance is currently at 16.5%, slightly above the 15% minimum policy requirement. Weidhorn warned that credit rating agencies look at the fund balance trend, stating, "If they see us spending it down every year, that to them says we need to put you on a credit watch."

**Community Input**
A public commenter expressed support for funding the council’s proposed changes but raised concerns about a recurring pattern of increased funding requests for the police department following controversies. The commenter stated, "It seems like deja vu all over again... I may have some issues with this going forward and just wanted them to be known." Members did not respond directly to this specific comment before the meeting moved to the closed session motion.

**Follow-Ups and Next Steps**
Staff agreed to several follow-up actions, including providing a detailed spreadsheet of the $2.7 million in identified savings, distinguishing between one-time and ongoing savings, and providing a list of potential efficiencies or cuts based on priority-based budgeting results. Staff will also provide monthly reports to the council on the progress of the policing-related action items and investigate the feasibility of allowing two-installment payments for Aston Park season passes. The council will hold a special Finance Committee meeting between March 27 and April 10 to "deep dive" into the budget and identify further cuts or revenue sources to address the $3.2 million gap. A full council budget work session is scheduled for April 10.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vdi-7hvLzLI
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3071/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vdi-7hvLzLI)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
