# City Council Meeting – March 13, 2018

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 13, 2018 11:00 AM EDT (2018-03-13T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5332/city-council-meeting-march-13-2018
**Outcome:** Council approved permanent road closures and board appointments unanimously and scheduled a work session on police accountability.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on March 13, 2018. The agenda included routine administrative items, presentations from local organizations, decisions on road closures and board appointments, and an extensive period of public comment. The council adopted the consent agenda unanimously and approved several specific actions regarding infrastructure and city boards. The majority of the meeting was dedicated to hearing from the public, with the Mayor noting that the council intended to listen to community concerns rather than take immediate action on the topics raised.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The council voted unanimously to adopt the consent agenda. Three motions regarding the permanent closure of rights-of-way were also passed unanimously: the unopened right-of-way at 85 Deaver Street (Paper Alley), the unopened right-of-way on Deaver Street south of Howard, and a portion of Peachtree Street near Jake Rusher Park to allow for park expansion.

Regarding appointments to city boards and commissions, the council voted unanimously to appoint Amy Kemp and Scott Farkas to the Audit Committee, with interviews scheduled for three other candidates. The Board of Adjustments saw the unanimous appointment of Warren Williams and Sarah Katzmark as alternates, with the remaining slot to be re-advertised. Wayne Wheeler was unanimously appointed to the Noise Ordinance Appeals Board, and Justin Thompson was unanimously appointed to the Recreation Board. For the Riverfront Redevelopment Group, the council unanimously voted to interview three candidates for one open position. The Homeless Initiative Advisory Council committee suggested re-advertising for the opening with a focus on candidates currently or recently experiencing homelessness, a suggestion accepted by the Vice Mayor. The Multimodal Transportation Commission requested to postpone its appointments until the following month.

**Discussion Highlights and Presentations**
The council heard presentations from the Asheville Museum of Science (AMAS), the Racial Justice Coalition (RJC), and representatives from the NAACP and Southerners on New Ground. The AMAS Executive Director discussed the museum’s move to the Wells Fargo building and its current low level of municipal funding compared to peer institutions. The RJC and other groups presented recommendations regarding a recent police use-of-force incident involving Johnny Rush. Their recommendations included calls for trauma-informed care for the victim, written consent for searches, the establishment of citizen review boards, and improved complaint processes.

Council Member Shanika Williams moved to enter closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding privileged and confidential information, attorney-client privilege, and personnel privacy. The motion was seconded, though no vote tally was recorded in the transcript.

**Community Input**
Public comment was the most significant portion of the meeting, with residents and community groups speaking primarily about the police use-of-force incident involving Johnny Rush, systemic racism in policing, and the need for accountability.
*   **Police Accountability and Systemic Racism:** Multiple public commenters expressed outrage over the incident. A representative of the Beloved of Asheville Homeless Voice Group called for cutting the police budget to fund housing and healthcare. A mother and grandmother criticized the city’s response, stating that "zero tolerance" should mean immediate criminal charges and the resignation of the Mayor and Vice Mayor. Another resident called for the resignation of council members who did not know about the incident until it was leaked.
*   **Policy and Oversight:** Speakers from Grace Covenant Presbyterian Church urged the council to adopt recommendations from the Blue Ribbon Committee and ensure the Chief of Police reports directly to the City Manager and Attorney. A representative from the Southern Coalition for Social Justice presented data showing that Black drivers in Asheville were searched at the highest rate in the state and urged the council to prohibit low-level discretionary stops. A public commenter shared her son’s experience of being beaten during an involuntary commitment order, requesting immediate review of body cam footage and the creation of a citizen’s review board.
*   **Specific Demands:** A public commenter presented a ten-point demand list including the resignation of those involved in covering up the Rush incident, reallocating $1 million from the police budget to community programs, and making body cam videos public property. Another commenter argued that resignations allow officials to keep pensions and demanded that officials be fired instead. A public commenter apologized to Mr. Rush, stating he was not surprised by the incident and asking the council to identify who knew what was happening and when.
*   **Support for Police:** A representative from the Asheville Police Department stated that the department does not condone the actions of the officer involved and criticized the council for prejudging officers. The FOP President condemned the video but stated it does not represent the entire department, emphasizing the need for patience and support for officers.
*   **Member Response:** Council Member Keith Young spoke before public comment began, stating, "I'm not apologizing to the police. I'm not apologizing to the chief... I want to see a program based by the police force that promotes minority recruitment with substantial pay."
*   **Other Topics:** A resident of 180 Peachtree Street raised concerns about speeding traffic on adjacent Cedar Lane, which a staff member directed her to take up with the head of the transportation department. A public commenter noted that the museum’s funding structure was not in line with other leading museums, and a council member clarified that AMAS had not applied for the city’s strategic partnership fund that year. A public commenter expressed outrage that the Asheville Rescue Mission stopped serving breakfast and refused to shelter men during Code Purple events. A General Manager of a staffing agency spoke on behalf of employees who lost jobs due to the abrupt termination of a city contract with the U.S. Cellular Center.

**Follow-ups**
*   A staff member agreed to provide the contact information for the Director of Water Resources to a public commenter who requested a meeting to discuss connecting their neighborhood to the city water system due to high radium levels in their wells.
*   A staff member directed a public commenter to contact the head of the transportation department regarding traffic calming measures on Cedar Lane.
*   The Mayor announced that a work session would be held in one week, with a portion specifically devoted to the topics raised in public comment regarding police accountability and racial justice.
*   City Manager Gary Jackson stated he would check on the status of the interim contract for the staffing agency mentioned by a public commenter.

**Impact**
This meeting highlighted a significant divide in the community regarding policing and public safety. While the council approved routine administrative and infrastructure items, the public comment period revealed deep frustration among residents over the handling of the Johnny Rush incident and broader issues of racial equity in law enforcement. The council’s decision to hold a work session the following week indicates an intent to engage further with these specific community concerns, while the postponement of Multimodal Transportation Commission appointments suggests a delay in finalizing that specific board's composition.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_x3qyZPrQcs
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3087/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_x3qyZPrQcs)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
