# City Council Meeting - February 13, 2018

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** February 13, 2018 11:00 AM EST (2018-02-13T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5335/city-council-meeting-february-13-2018
**Outcome:** Council unanimously rejected the Merriman Avenue road proposal and postponed board and commission appointments to March.

## Summary

The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on February 13, 2018, addressing a range of administrative, infrastructure, and community planning topics. The agenda included the announcement of the City Manager’s retirement, routine approvals, and detailed presentations on urban forestry, water conservation, and the restructuring of the Human Relations Commission. The Council also debated a significant transportation proposal regarding Merriman Avenue and addressed appointments for city boards and commissions.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Council took several formal actions during the meeting. A motion was made and seconded to approve the consent agenda, which includes routine administrative matters; however, no vote is recorded in the summary for this specific item. Regarding the Merriman Avenue project, the Council voted unanimously to reject the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) proposal, citing that it fails to meet city goals. The Council passed a resolution requesting that NCDOT collaborate with city staff to develop alternative plans that align with adopted city plans and safety standards for all users. Additionally, the Council voted to postpone board and commission appointments to the March 13, 2018 meeting and agreed to re-advertise for Audit Committee members, specifically seeking applicants with an active Certified Public Accountant (CPA) license. The Council also voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding a lawsuit involving the City of Asheville and Robert H. Frost.

**Discussion Highlights**
The meeting opened with the announcement of City Manager Gary Jackson’s retirement, effective December 31, 2018. The Mayor read a letter praising Jackson’s service, stating, "You have served the city selflessly, wisely, and with grace and integrity. Our community is forever indebted to you." Jackson responded, "I'm at a loss for words... It's been an honor and a privilege... We have the best team going in the organization right now."

The Council reviewed a gap analysis from the Tree Commission, which highlighted tree canopy loss due to dense development. The Tree Commission Chair noted, "It's evident that Asheville is now losing some of his tree cover as the city becomes more densely developed... it's very important that our future urban forests is well planned and is not an afterthought." In the water sector, the Director of Water Resources reported that the city has achieved significant growth over the past 10 years without extracting additional water from sources, an achievement the Mayor described as "tremendous."

Regarding the Human Relations Commission (HRC), the Council received a Blue Ribbon Committee report recommending restructuring, including new mission statements and staffing needs. The Vice Mayor stated that the Council would "gratefully accept your report" and asked the legal department to draft enabling legislation to form the commission. On the Merriman Avenue project, a council member observed, "I think it's very telling that the community itself thinks like a road guide [diet] and wants this to be a more multimodal city."

**Community Input**
Public comment was received on several agenda items. Regarding the HRC report, a public commenter expressed concern that the Blue Ribbon Committee was asked to do an "almost impossible task" in a short timeframe, urging the Council to support the budget increase for the equity department and ensure the equity manager reports directly to the City Manager. Another commenter, a downtown business owner, urged full support for the staffing recommendations, stating, "You have set up a skilled black woman to fail... make her your conscience... We're only paying lip service to equality and justice otherwise." A third commenter asked that the equity/inclusion manager be aligned with top city offices. No specific council members replied directly to these comments during the recorded segment.

On the Merriman Avenue project, a representative of the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County opposed the NCDOT proposal, arguing it would cause "substantial and irrevocable damage" to historic districts. An executive director from Ashland Bikes opposed the current design, citing the need for safe streets. A new resident from Maryland spoke in favor of protecting walkability in the Grove Park area, urging the Council to minimize lanes and slow traffic. A North Asheville resident supported a "road diet," arguing that adding lanes increases flooding and fatalities. No specific council members replied directly to these comments.

During end-of-meeting public comment, a representative from the Audubon Society urged the Council to prohibit certain non-native invasive plants to protect habitat. A public commenter who had experienced homelessness described the situation in Asheville as a "public emergency." A council member responded to this commenter, asking if they had met with the homeless coordinator. The commenter confirmed they had attended several HIAC meetings. The council member added, "I just want to make sure that if the Council receives the recommendations, they'll ask staff to review them. So I'm not trying to filter. I'm trying to facilitate for you."

**Follow-ups**
Staff and Council members outlined several next steps. The City Manager’s office stated they would "make sure that the recommendations are brought forward with the other recommendations in the budget process" regarding the Tree Commission’s gap analysis. The Council indicated the HRC report would go to the Boards and Commissions committee to begin the process of creating or recreating the commission. For the Merriman Avenue project, the Transportation Department Director stated that the city has submitted comments to NCDOT and is working on a list of projects to ensure the city is "at the table," with a meeting being scheduled between the Council, MPO members, and NCDOT officials. Staff will re-advertise for Audit Committee appointments, emphasizing the need for active CPAs, with appointments to be considered at the March 13, 2018 meeting.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions reflect the Council’s focus on balancing infrastructure development with community preservation and equity. The rejection of the initial Merriman Avenue plan signals a shift toward multimodal, safety-focused transportation design that aligns with local goals. The acceptance of the HRC restructuring report and the commitment to draft enabling legislation indicate a move toward formalizing the commission’s role in equity and inclusion. The confirmation of water efficiency achievements and the urban forestry planning efforts highlight the city’s ongoing management of natural resources and environmental health.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtPbOedndZ4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3240/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtPbOedndZ4)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
