# City Council Meeting - November 28, 2017

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** November 28, 2017 11:00 AM EST (2017-11-28T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5339/city-council-meeting-november-28-2017
**Outcome:** Council approved the rezoning of 1568 Brevard Road to high-density residential and the sale of a Broadway parcel with affordable housing requirements, and amended the Haywood Road form code to exclude lodging.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on November 28, 2017, to address a range of financial, planning, and development issues. The meeting began with a resolution proclaiming December 2017 as “Better Buses Together Month,” celebrating the fifth anniversary of the People’s Transit Campaign. The council also reviewed its first-quarter financial reports, which indicated that expenditures are slightly under budget and revenues are tracking as anticipated. Additionally, the council received an update on its strategic priorities regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion, and reviewed a new mapping tool that inventories all city-owned real estate.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The council voted to approve the consent agenda with the exception of two items. Item F, the Food Action Plan, was approved. Item G, a contract with Asheville Staffing, was moved to the December 19 agenda to allow for further review regarding living wage practices and staffing options. In planning and development matters, the council approved a resolution releasing a deed restriction on 1568 Brevard Road for economic development purposes and subsequently approved rezoning the property from Industrial to Residential Multifamily High Density (RM-16). The council also approved amendments to the Haywood Road form-based code, including the creation of a new HR-7 district and the exclusion of lodging facilities of all types from all districts in the Haywood form code. Furthermore, the council approved a zoning map amendment rezoning a specific section of Haywood Road from the HR5 Live/Work District to the HR7 Traditional Community District. Finally, the council adopted a resolution authorizing the sale of a 0.38-acre city-owned parcel at 427 Broadway Street to Reed Creek Greenway Plaza LLC for $115,000. This sale is contingent on deed restrictions requiring a minimum of eight affordable housing units at 60% Area Median Income for 25 years and limiting short-term rentals for 25 years.

**Discussion Highlights**
Financial presentations highlighted the city’s fiscal health, with the Chief Financial Officer noting that the fire department is 0.1% under budget for salaries and wages. A representative from DEC Associates presented the city’s new AAA credit rating from Moody’s Investor Services, stating, "It takes about a hundred years to get your triple A back. And you've done that and I applaud you." The Interim Assistant City Manager emphasized the integration of equity metrics into capital project decision-making, noting, "Equity is an actual factor in our decisions. How is this helping underserved populations?" The Director of Planning & Urban Design praised the new property inventory tool, stating, "This has totally brought us out of the stone [age]... into something really good."

Regarding the Haywood Road amendments, several council members discussed the impact of short-term rentals. One council member argued that removing the right to build lodging would prevent pop-ups before a comprehensive threshold change could be made, adding, "I am not a lobbyist for Airbnb or short-term rentals or anything like that... I think you can't make Asheville, North Carolina, Beer City, USA, and then complain about the fallout." Another council member predicted that the new council would likely change the policy on short-term rentals, noting, "I predict that we're gonna end up banning whole house rentals citywide and permitting accessory dwelling units at least by my count of the new council."

**Community Input**
Public comment was received on several agenda items. Regarding 1568 Brevard Road, a resident expressed concern about traffic, wildlife, and runoff, arguing that high-density multifamily development is too hard on the community. Another public commenter suggested the council wait to make a decision to allow for more research on alternative uses for the 137-acre site. No specific member responded directly to these comments before the vote was taken.

On the Haywood Road form code, the President of the West Asheville Business Association urged the council to retain lodging as a permitted use, while a representative for the Land of the Sky Association of Realtors argued that restricting short-term rentals could impact property value. A resident representing neighbors on Bruce Muntz Circle advocated for zoning that supports a living community rather than a "recreation zone" for visitors. In response, a council member noted that Planning & Urban Design would re-look the lodging facility exception across the city in December or January. Another council member supported the removal of lodging by right, emphasizing that conditional zoning remains available.

A public commenter asked if the council had the power to declare a temporary moratorium on short-term rentals. A council member responded that the council should "talk to our lawyer" regarding General Statute 168-381, which allows for moratoriums under certain circumstances. Another public commenter expressed frustration at being interrupted during their three-minute comment, arguing it was unfair that a previous speaker was allowed to exceed their time limit. The chair apologized, explaining, "I do sometimes interrupt speakers if they are saying things that are incorrect. because I don't want the public to get misinformation." Finally, a public commenter requested that minutes be posted before the next meeting to allow residents time to research them. A council member confirmed that public comment is allowed on consent agenda items and explained the standard process for removing items for separate consideration.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to look at options for hiring more city employees instead of contracting out and to provide legal options regarding living wage inquiries for the Asheville Staffing contract, which was moved to the December 19 agenda. A council member stated that Planning & Urban Design will look at the lodging facility exception (20 guest rooms or less) across the city in December or January to allow the council to consider it in the aggregate. A council member also stated they would "talk to our lawyer" regarding the legality of a temporary moratorium on short-term rentals.

**Impact**
These decisions impact residents through changes in neighborhood zoning and the availability of affordable housing. The rezoning of 1568 Brevard Road to high-density residential and the sale of 427 Broadway Street with strict affordable housing and short-term rental restrictions will shape development in those areas. The exclusion of lodging from the Haywood Road form code and the potential citywide review of lodging exceptions reflect the council's response to concerns about short-term rentals and their impact on residential communities. The approval of the Food Action Plan and the city’s strong financial standing, including the AAA credit rating, underscore the council’s focus on long-term fiscal responsibility and community development.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_K_vArsKiD8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3084/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_K_vArsKiD8)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
