# City Council Meeting - March 28, 2017

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 28, 2017 11:00 AM EDT (2017-03-28T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5352/city-council-meeting-march-28-2017

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on March 28, 2017, to address a variety of agenda items including accessibility improvements, zoning requests, and community planning initiatives. The meeting opened with the recognition of a donation from the Asheville Breakfast Rotary Club for an audio frequency induction loop system, designed to assist residents with hearing loss in the Council Chamber. The Council also approved two proclamations for National Service Recognition Day and Tartan Day. Following the approval of the consent agenda, which included a disparity study and a parking study, the Council moved to substantive discussions regarding the Haywood Street community visioning process and two conditional zoning public hearings.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Haywood Street Advisory Team’s presentation on the former Sister Cities building site. The team outlined a vision statement and recommended uses that sought a compromise between park space and commercial or active uses. After reviewing the visioning outcomes, the Council voted to direct staff to design and issue a Request for Proposals (RFP) for a design firm to deliver design options based on these findings. During the discussion, a Council member suggested that staff include significant public involvement, such as a charrette, in the design process, and the Mayor stated her assumption that staff would build public involvement into the process.

The Council held public hearings on two conditional zoning requests. The first request, for the Jewish Community Center (JCC) expansion at 236 Charlotte Street and 336 Hillside Street, was approved with amendments. The Council voted to allow two-way access rather than egress-only on Hillside Street and to reduce the fenestration requirement from 30% to 20%. Staff recommended support for this request, noting it was aligned with city goals. The second request, for 95 Charlotte Street (the historic Patton Parker House), sought to rezone the property from an Office Conditional Zone to a Community Business zone to allow lodging or short-term rental use in an accessory structure. One Council member recused themselves from this item due to a reciprocal referral relationship with the applicant.

The motion to approve the 95 Charlotte Street rezoning failed with a 3-3 vote. Proponents argued the change fit the surrounding commercial pattern and preserved the historic property, while opponents expressed concern that rezoning specifically for short-term rentals set a troubling precedent and removed residential units from the housing pool. One Council member stated they were inclined to deny the request because they did not hear a valid reason to change the zoning other than the applicant’s desire to make more money. Another member noted that the precedent of rezoning for the specific purpose of short-term rentals was troubling. Because the vote was tied, the motion to rezone the property did not pass.

Public comment was received on several items. Regarding the Haywood Street visioning process, residents expressed support for the volunteers who reconciled polarized opinions and requested that the design process consider "missing middle" housing, access to green space, and the involvement of local artists. A public commenter from North Asheville urged the Council to focus the area primarily on local and artist communities, while another from Kenilworth argued the area should serve as an economic stimulator for low-income locals. No Council members or staff members directly responded to these specific arguments. On the 95 Charlotte Street hearing, public commenters were divided, with supporters citing the success of nearby historic lodging and opponents raising concerns about traffic, noise, and the loss of long-term housing. No Council members or staff members directly responded to the arguments made by public commenters during the hearing portion.

In general public comment, a resident urged the City Council and staff to focus energy on creating Asheville as a "solar city" rather than focusing solely on other industries. In response, a Council member stated they were encouraged by the comment, noting that they were working toward a net-zero home and would invite the commenter to their house in about two months. The meeting concluded with the Council moving into closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding pending lawsuits, specifically *PHG Asheville LLC v. City of Asheville* and *Cron v. City of Asheville*.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to report back on the specifics of the parking study recommendations. Additionally, staff and the JCC applicant agreed to clarify the ordinance language regarding the Hillside Street driveway to ensure it is not limited to "egress only," subject to technical staff review. No other explicit follow-ups were agreed upon regarding the failed 95 Charlotte Street rezoning motion or the general public comments on solar energy.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ulEaQLOxCB8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3093/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ulEaQLOxCB8)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
