# City Council Meeting - March 14, 2017

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 14, 2017 11:00 AM EDT (2017-03-14T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5353/city-council-meeting-march-14-2017
**Outcome:** Council approved the 2017-18 fees and charges package and the permanent closure of the Austin Avenue alley, both unanimously.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on March 14, 2017, addressing a range of administrative, financial, and public safety topics. The agenda included the approval of routine documents, a public hearing on infrastructure changes, updates on the city’s fee structure, and appointments to advisory committees. The session also featured significant public comment regarding the proposed police budget and local social services.

**Key Decisions**
The council voted unanimously to approve the permanent closure of the alley between 7 and 19 Austin Avenue following a public hearing. This decision was supported by the Interim Streets Division Manager, who noted that the city had reached out to all city departments and local utilities without receiving objections, and that the Multimodal Transportation Committee had already approved the motion. Additionally, the council voted unanimously to approve the 2017-18 fees and charges package, which included adjustments to water, stormwater, transit, parking, and development services fees. The council also voted unanimously to appoint Randy Stout to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee, a motion moved by the Vice Mayor. Finally, the council voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with an attorney regarding privileged information.

**Discussion Highlights**
During the review of the 2017-18 fees and charges, Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, explained that the rate adjustments represent a continuation of financial plans presented to the council in previous years. He specified that residential water rates would increase by 1.5% and stormwater fees would increase by 5%. Regarding the alley closure, the Interim Streets Division Manager requested the council’s approval, citing the lack of objections from utility providers and the prior approval by the Multimodal Transportation Committee.

A notable portion of the meeting involved a discussion between the Mayor and a council member regarding the Haywood Street task force. The Mayor expressed concern over online discussions and private emails between a council member and the task force consultant, stating it was her obligation to raise the issue to ensure task force members could work without undue influence from the council. The council member explained that their communication was triggered by bullying within the task force and a discrepancy between the promised and actual processes. The council member stated they would try to refrain from interfering with task forces in the future, noting that while they may have used strong language in a private email, they viewed the bullying as a more serious issue.

**Community Input**
Public comment focused primarily on the proposed $1 million budget increase for the police department. A public commenter from Kenilworth urged the council to require appropriate data before approving the increase, requesting that the council invite a criminal justice attorney from the Southern Coalition for Social Justice to present low-cost, proven alternatives and data on stop-and-search practices. Another public commenter, representing a homeless voice project, thanked the council for the appointment of Randy Stout to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee but argued that increasing policing leads to disparate outcomes for people of color and those without homes, urging the council to invest the funds in long-term solutions such as housing, jobs, and public transit. A third public commenter stated that Asheville is one of the least affordable cities in the U.S. and argued that increasing policing protects property values for the wealthy while exacerbating inequalities, requesting that the funds be directed toward affordable housing, higher wages, and transportation access. A fourth public commenter expressed concern about the Western North Carolina Age Project’s needle exchange program, alleging that underage teenagers were receiving needles and using drugs in the parking lot, and demanded an investigation. Members did not respond to the public comments regarding the police budget or the needle exchange program.

**Follow-ups**
A council member asked staff to return in a year or a year and a half to evaluate the rental rates for the city-owned property at 14 Riverside Drive, noting that the initial rates were a guess. Additionally, a council member asked staff to provide an estimate of how extending parking meter hours into the night, enabled by new meters with lights, would increase parking revenues.

**Impact**
These decisions and discussions highlight the council’s ongoing management of municipal finances and public safety. The approval of the fee adjustments ensures the continuation of planned financial trajectories for water and stormwater services, while the alley closure addresses specific infrastructure maintenance needs. The public comments reflect significant community debate regarding the allocation of police funding versus social services, with residents advocating for data-driven approaches and investments in housing and community resources. The internal discussion regarding the Haywood Street task force underscores the council’s attention to the independence of its advisory bodies.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unOoP2Xulp0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3090/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unOoP2Xulp0)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
