# City Council Meeting - February 28, 2017

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** February 28, 2017 11:00 AM EST (2017-02-28T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5354/city-council-meeting-february-28-2017
**Outcome:** Council appointed three new members to the Board of Education 5-5-5 and voted to conduct a poll on district-based elections.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on February 28, 2017, to address a range of municipal issues, including public safety, education, transportation, and land use. The meeting began with the Neighborhood Advisory Committee presenting the first annual Volunteer of the Year award to a resident of the Malvern Hills neighborhood. The Mayor subsequently proclaimed March 10, 2017, as Zelda Sayre Fitzgerald Day, recognizing her historical connection to Asheville and upcoming cultural events.

In the consent agenda, the Council approved a resolution denouncing threats against the Jewish community, a response to a recent bomb threat at the Asheville Jewish Community Center. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated, "Hate crimes threats or intimidation that targets the Jewish people or any other people will not be tolerated... I think this council has been quick to step up whenever we've seen acts of hatred targeting anyone." The motion to approve the consent agenda, including this resolution, was taken and passed.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the appointment of three new members to the Asheville City Board of Education. Council Member Keith Bryant emphasized the gravity of the decision, noting, "This is probably, I think, the most important decision I probably will make here on council... It’s not just about what people have on paper, but what they bring as far as passion and being good advocates to the folks in the community." The Council voted to appoint Patricia Griffin, James Lee, and Joyce Brown, with a final tally of 5-5-5 for the three candidates. Their appointments are effective April 1, 2017.

The Council also discussed the potential for district-based elections, noting that a state senator intends to introduce a bill mandating such districts. Council Member Cecil Bothwell expressed frustration with the state legislature's intent, stating, "Obviously, it’s extremely disappointing that we’re back to Raleigh says and it doesn’t matter what Asheville residents say." Council Member Gwen Whistler added, "Disappointing is an understatement. I think that this is... more of the same kind of overreach the ignoring municipalities self-determination... I ask you whether you are serving as a representative of the people or not." Following this discussion, the Council voted to conduct a poll to gauge public opinion on the issue.

Regarding land use, the Mayor proposed reopening the discussion on the definition of "homestay" to potentially allow renting rooms within a primary residence, distinct from detached Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs). The Council did not take a formal vote to change the ordinance but expressed interest in having staff explore this concept. Additionally, the Council discussed a request to allow a local business to advertise on its vehicles. The City Attorney explained that due to First Amendment constraints, the city cannot allow advertising for one specific business without allowing it for all, which would require a broader ordinance change.

**Community Input**
During public comment, a resident spoke regarding the districting poll, requesting that anyone being polled be provided with an information sheet explaining the pros and cons of districting prior to stating their preference. The Chair noted the comment and moved to the vote. Another public commenter addressed a Council member regarding the purchase of a home in Arden, questioning their residency status and the details of their loan application. No member responded to this comment in the transcript; the Chair thanked the speaker and closed the public comment period.

**Follow-ups and Next Steps**
Staff agreed to conduct a scientific poll regarding district elections, with results potentially available by the beginning of May, though the Council expressed a desire to accelerate the timeline. Staff were directed to explore expanding the homestay definition to include rooms under the roof of a house and to examine the impacts of short-term rentals in the Central Business District. Staff were also asked to contact Airbnb and other short-term rental platforms regarding enforcement cooperation. The Transportation Department provided a quarterly update on the I-26 Connector project, noting that the Request for Qualifications for a consultant team was released on February 22, with proposals due March 17 and a contract award decision scheduled for April 25. The City Manager stated that staff would return to the committee with a plan on how to work with business groups and property owners regarding signage and mobility needs during the upcoming River District construction.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItjbEn1-aCA
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3092/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItjbEn1-aCA)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
