# City Council Meeting - May 17, 2016

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** May 17, 2016 11:00 AM EDT (2016-05-17T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5367/city-council-meeting-may-17-2016
**Outcome:** Council adopted the Asheville in Motion transportation plan and denied the proposal to allow accessory dwelling units for short-term rentals, creating a task force to study the issue.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on May 17, 2016, to address a wide-ranging agenda that included the adoption of a new transportation plan, a public hearing on the annual operating budget, and significant deliberations regarding short-term rentals in residential areas. The meeting also featured the selection of members for a new advisory team and a review of upcoming vacancies on city committees.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Council approved the consent agenda and unanimously adopted the Asheville in Motion (AIM) Plan, a multimodal transportation strategy developed over 1.5 years that integrates land use and transportation planning. In a major decision regarding housing, the Council unanimously denied a proposal to amend the Unified Development Ordinance to allow Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) to be used for guest accommodations (homestays). The Council found the expansion inconsistent with the comprehensive plan due to housing scarcity. However, the Council unanimously approved the creation of an ADU/Homestay Task Force to examine policies regarding ADUs used as short-term rentals, including concerns about long-term housing availability and potential strategies like caps or cooling-off periods. The Council also unanimously approved a technical amendment clarifying the definition of a "full-time resident" under the existing homestay ordinance. Additionally, the Council approved a Conditional Use Permit and a signage plan amendment for the Asheville Outlets project at 800 Brevard Road.

**Discussion Highlights**
The Mayor reported that the North Carolina Supreme Court heard Asheville’s water case in Morganton, with the opinion expected in August. The Council recognized the 2016 KALA class, noting that total scholarship money earned by students since 2008 will surpass $1.1 million. During the public hearing for the FY 2016-17 Annual Operating Budget, Finance Director Barbara Whitehorn presented a $170.4 million budget ($161 million net of transfers). No vote was taken on the budget at this meeting; the final vote is scheduled for June 14. The Council also finalized the selection of David Nutter, Susan Andrew, and Geronimo Owen for the Haywood Street Advisory Team, with the Chair noting that the first meeting for the newly selected team is scheduled for Thursday morning.

**Community Input**
Public comment was extensive during the budget and ADU hearings. Regarding the budget, a public commenter requested cutting the $2 million allocated for repairing outdated pools by half to fund new indoor pools. Several commenters, including a social worker and a resident, expressed concern about the new "Crime Analyst" position, arguing that funds should be directed toward infrastructure, transit, and jobs rather than increased policing. Other commenters thanked the Council for prioritizing transit funding, while one requested the removal of $2 million in capital improvements funding for the Asheville Art Museum.

During the ADU/Homestay hearing, public comment was divided. Multiple residents opposed the expansion, arguing that allowing ADUs as short-term rentals turns residential neighborhoods into commercial zones, reduces affordable housing for local workers, and benefits out-of-state investors. Others supported the change, stating that the income from ADU homestays allows them to remain in Asheville, and some proposed compromises such as grandfathering existing ADUs or implementing a ban on short-term rentals for new ADUs. A public commenter also suggested deferring any decision until the comprehensive plan process is completed. In response to concerns about the Crime Analyst position, the City Manager agreed to make a concerted effort to broadcast information about the position’s purpose on the city website.

**Follow-ups**
The City Manager agreed to publish information about the Crime Analyst position on the city website. The Chair noted that there is a public meeting on Thursday at 5:30 PM at Civic Sound and encouraged residents to check the city website for details. The Chair also explicitly asked the public to apply for vacancies on committees and commissions, noting that many positions would become available on June 30.

**Impact**
These decisions significantly shape the city’s approach to transportation and housing. The adoption of the AIM Plan establishes a new framework for multimodal transportation and street design. The denial of the ADU homestay expansion, paired with the creation of a task force, signals a cautious approach to short-term rentals in residential areas, prioritizing the preservation of long-term housing stock while seeking further study on the issue. The upcoming vote on the budget on June 14 will determine the city’s financial priorities for the coming year.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dHCbv95m8Dw
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3268/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dHCbv95m8Dw)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
