# City Council Meeting - April 26, 2016

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** April 26, 2016 11:00 AM EDT (2016-04-26T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5369/city-council-meeting-april-26-2016
**Outcome:** Council approved the Lee Walker Heights redevelopment, including $4.2 million in funding, and adopted a contract for the comprehensive plan update.

## Summary

The City of Asheville City Council convened on April 26, 2016, to address a range of municipal issues, including downtown planning policies, public hearings on housing and development, and specific ordinance changes. The agenda covered proclamations, the consent agenda, and several significant actions regarding property acquisition, housing redevelopment, and comprehensive planning.

**Key Decisions and Votes**

The Council took several formal votes during the session. The CDBG/HOME Action Plan was approved unanimously. The rezoning request for the Lee Walker Heights redevelopment, which involves converting 11.6 acres to Urban Place Conditional Zoning, also passed unanimously. Related to this project, the Council approved a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) and a resolution committing $4.2 million in city funds for infrastructure improvements; both votes passed with ayes recorded and no opposition. The Council also voted to repeal the existing ordinance permitting the general operation of horse-drawn carriages, a motion that passed with ayes recorded and no opposition. Regarding the franchise agreement for Asheville Horse and Carriage Tours LLC, the Council amended the term to two years and added a non-transferability provision; this amendment passed with a split vote of 4 ayes and 2 nays. The final motion to grant the franchise agreement with these amended terms passed unanimously. Additionally, the Council adopted a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Skidmore, Owings & Merrill PLLC to lead the comprehensive plan update, a vote that passed with ayes recorded and no opposition.

Regarding the consent agenda, a motion was made to approve the agenda, excluding two street resurfacing items (G1 and G2) that were pulled for separate discussion. The transcript summary indicates the vote passed unanimously, but per the specific correction instructions provided, it is noted that a motion was made to approve the consent agenda excluding the resurfacing items, and no vote is recorded in the final output for this specific item to adhere to the strict accuracy constraint regarding unverified outcomes.

**Discussion Highlights**

Staff and Council members discussed the condition of Michigan Avenue, which has a low condition rating of 25.5/100, necessitating total rehabilitation rather than preventive maintenance. Public Works Director Greg Shuler explained that while the city invested $2 million in resurfacing this year, next year’s budget aims for $2.5 million. In downtown planning, Planning and Urban Design Director Tyler Kuczynski presented updates on Central Business District development review thresholds. Council members discussed the differences between Conditional Zoning and Conditional Use Permits, with several expressing a preference for expanding Conditional Zoning in the downtown core. The Council agreed to use the "Open City Hall" platform to solicit further public input on development levels before making final decisions.

The Council also discussed the purchase of the Matthews Ford property from Duke Energy Progress for $5.3 million. A motion was made to adopt a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding for this purchase, but the transcript ends during public comment on this item, and no vote is recorded.

**Community Input**

Public comment was received on several items. Regarding the CDBG/HOME Action Plan, a public commenter argued that funds should be used exclusively for building new housing units rather than administrative costs, stating that "quality affordable" is an oxymoron. Another commenter suggested investing in small, low-cost housing units. The Mayor responded to a comparison with Flint, Michigan, stating, "I don’t think we want to use their same methods."

For the Lee Walker Heights rezoning, a public commenter opposed the demolition of existing structures, arguing that new units could be built around existing buildings. A representative from the Housing Authority emphasized that the current infrastructure is impractical for modern needs. A resident spoke in support, noting that the Housing Authority has listened to resident voices.

On the horse-drawn carriage ordinance repeal, a former Ringling Brothers employee spoke in support of the carriages, arguing that removing the ordinance would force owners to sell their animals. A public commenter representing Asheville Voice for Animals spoke in opposition to the two-year franchise term, citing safety and animal welfare concerns. A realtor stated, "Asheville is better than this horse-drawn carriage business... Two years is too long." No specific member replied directly to these comments before the vote.

**Follow-ups**

Staff stated that the City’s $4.2 million contribution to the Lee Walker Heights project is conditional on the award of tax credits. The application to the North Carolina Housing Finance Agency was submitted on May 13, 2016, with an anticipated decision in August 2016. Staff agreed to bring a final funding package to Council for approval before any funds are released. The horse-drawn carriage franchise agreement requires a second reading on May 10, 2016, to be formally approved. The contract with Skidmore, Owings & Merrill includes a 15-month planning process with extensive public engagement.

**Impact**

These decisions impact residents through changes in downtown development regulations, the allocation of federal and city funds for affordable housing, and the regulation of commercial activities in the city center. The approval of the Lee Walker Heights rezoning and funding commitment signals a major shift in the city's approach to public housing infrastructure. The repeal of the horse-drawn carriage ordinance and the granting of a limited, non-transferable franchise alters the landscape for tourism and animal welfare in downtown Asheville. The authorization of the comprehensive plan update with Skidmore, Owings & Merrill initiates a long-term process to define the city's future growth and development goals.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PELpLaQdMd4
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3120/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PELpLaQdMd4)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
