# City Council Meeting - March 8, 2016

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** March 8, 2016 11:00 AM EST (2016-03-08T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5372/city-council-meeting-march-8-2016

## Summary

The City of Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on March 8, 2016. The agenda included a proclamation for Zelda Sayre Fitzgerald Day, a consent agenda, presentations on the Lee Walker Heights Master Plan and police body-worn cameras, a financial report, a public hearing on street renaming, and discussions regarding the Haywood Street property visioning process and the 33 & 35 Page Avenue building.

**Key Decisions**
The Council voted to approve the renaming of sections of Merritt Street to resolve mail delivery confusion; the south section was renamed "Bird Dog Way" and the north section "Merritt Park Lane," with the motion passing with no opposition. Regarding the deteriorating 33 & 35 Page Avenue building, which was deemed unsafe due to water intrusion and mold, the Council voted 5-1 to demolish the structure. A subsequent motion to approve a budget amendment of approximately $115,000 for the demolition passed unanimously. The Council also unanimously appointed Sandra Frem-Pong to the Hub Community and Economic Development Alliance and Kim Roney to the Multi-Modal Transportation Commission. Additionally, the Council unanimously approved a resolution to contract with the Asheville Design Center for the Haywood Street visioning process, a $15,000 budget amendment to fund it, and the composition of the 16-member advisory team.

Regarding the consent agenda, motions were made to approve routine items, including Henderson County transit funding and a fare-free bus day for Primary Election Day on March 15. However, no vote is recorded in the summary for these specific consent items.

**Discussion Highlights**
The Council discussed the implementation of body-worn cameras for the Police Department. Chief Hooper stated that the policy was developed through extensive research to align with best practices. John Maddox from the City Attorney’s Office noted that the policy includes provisions to balance transparency with privacy. Staff presented options for the 33 & 35 Page Avenue building, noting that renovation would cost over $500,000, while demolition would cost approximately $115,000. A Council member explained that the building inspector had posted the structure as unsafe because water intrusion was affecting the electrical panel, and that even with additional repairs, there remained a gap of over a quarter of a million dollars to make the building habitable.

In the general public comment period, the Chair clarified that the Governance Committee determined Asheville does not have a bathroom ordinance that needs fixing, unlike Charlotte, and that a press release would be issued to clarify this. Regarding the I-26 highway expansion, the Chair stated that the Council’s position is in favor of progress and improvements, noting they had spoken with state representatives regarding a December resolution supporting an alternative route.

**Community Input**
Public commenters raised several concerns regarding the body-worn camera policy. One commenter argued that the policy needs explicit disciplinary actions for officers who fail to upload or erase video and expressed concern that a clause allowing the Chief to "surreptitiously record" other employees could be used to spy on staff. Another commenter recommended retaining footage for longer than 60 days to allow individuals in jail to subpoena evidence; a Council member clarified that footage part of a criminal charge is retained as evidence, while the 60-day rule applies to non-evidentiary footage due to privacy concerns. A third commenter expressed concern that the city is spending over $300,000 on cameras while the public has little access, arguing this lacks accountability mechanisms.

Regarding the Haywood Street advisory team, a public commenter expressed concern that the group was not representative of the general public and alleged a Downtown Commission member donated money to the Design Center to influence the outcome. A Council member clarified that a $5,000 donation from Friends of St. Lawrence Green was intended to show broad support beyond the Asheville Downtown Association. Another commenter from the Homeless Coalition argued resources should be directed toward police and fire services rather than park aesthetics. A representative from Asheville Sister Cities requested inclusion on the advisory board due to their stake in the 33 Page building, to which a Council member noted that adding them would expand the committee size.

Concerning the 33 & 35 Page Avenue building, a public commenter from the Preservation Society urged the Council not to rush demolition, noting the building is a contributing structure in the historic district. A Council member stated that while agreeing with the sentiment for more process, the building’s condition and cost made demolition the most logical choice. Another commenter requested city funding for repairs so the organization could take over interior rehabilitation, prompting a Council member to ask how the organization’s fiscal health had improved to allow them to take on these costs. A former mayor argued the building is an appreciating asset, and another public commenter suggested using Affordable Housing Trust Fund money to renovate the lower level for affordable housing.

**Follow-ups**
Staff agreed to finalize a hire memo for a law enforcement technology specialist, process the purchase order for the initial 60 cameras, apply for state and federal grant funding, conduct a complete assessment of the body-worn camera program at the end of the year, and provide a detailed cost breakdown of the estimated $300,000 annual ongoing cost during the budget work session. For the Haywood Street project, staff agreed to draft application questions for at-large advisory seats, ask the Civic Center Commission if they wish to have a seat, and approach the Buskers Alliance regarding representation. Staff also agreed to proceed with the demolition of the 33 & 35 Page Avenue building, including a competitive bid and seeking advisory input from the Downtown Commission and Historic Resources Commission, and to continue working with Asheville Sister Cities to provide temporary space and storage. Finally, staff agreed to issue a press release clarifying the Governance Committee’s findings regarding the bathroom ordinance.

**Impact**
These decisions impact residents through changes to local street names, which will streamline mail delivery, and the demolition of an unsafe building on Page Avenue, which will clear the site for future development. The approval of the Haywood Street visioning process and advisory team establishes a framework for community input on downtown redevelopment. The body-worn camera program aims to enhance police accountability, with staff committed to evaluating the policy and costs in the coming year. The fare-free bus day for election day is intended to facilitate voter access, with staff planning to investigate further fare-free options for early voting.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlkwlM75v9c
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3113/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlkwlM75v9c)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
