# City Council Meeting - September 8, 2015

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** September 8, 2015 11:00 AM EDT (2015-09-08T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5382/city-council-meeting-september-8-2015
**Outcome:** Council adopted the Historic Preservation Master Plan and approved the conditional rezoning of the Haw Creek Commons property.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on September 8, 2015, to address a range of urban development, preservation, and administrative matters. The meeting began with special recognitions, including proclamations for Minority Enterprise Development Week and the International Day of Peace. The Council also acknowledged the City Manager’s victory in the Grand Fondo bicycle race. The agenda proceeded to the consent agenda, where the Council accepted all items unanimously, except for Item H, which was pulled for a hearing scheduled for October 13.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to land use and zoning decisions. The Council unanimously adopted the final draft of the Historic Preservation Master Plan for Asheville and Buncombe County, integrating it into the comprehensive plan. In zoning matters, the Council unanimously passed a resolution to permanently close an alley between Wyoming Road and Keebler Road to facilitate infill development. Additionally, the Council unanimously approved two amendments for 200 Ashland Avenue: a rezoning from Regional Business District to Central Business District (CBD) and a height zone map amendment to "intermediate." The Council also unanimously approved a UDO amendment creating a new "Cat Café" land use category within the CBD, supporting a plan by Brother Wolf Animal Rescue to combine feline adoption with retail sales.

The Council reviewed a modification to a 2005 Conditional Use Permit for Biltmore Gardens, which reduces total commercial square footage from approximately 15,000 to 10,000 square feet and eliminates one of four originally approved buildings. This modification was approved unanimously, subject to site plan conditions; the findings of fact and conclusions of law will appear on the consent agenda in two weeks for final approval. The most contentious item was the conditional rezoning of the Haw Creek Commons property from Residential Single-Family Medium Density to Institutional Conditional Zone. After amending the original motion to remove the condition allowing for the continuous production and export of tiny homes, the Council unanimously approved the conditional rezoning, which prohibits ongoing tiny home construction beyond the initial 10 units.

Regarding appointments, the Council unanimously reappointed Julie Mayfield, Edward Hay, and Jerome Jones to the Hub Community Economic Development Alliance. The Council unanimously appointed Dean Pistor, Helen Hyatt, Laura Carlson, and Pat Dennehy to fill four vacancies on the Recreation Board. For the Tourism Development Authority (TDA), the Council agreed to transition appointments to a process similar to the Board of Education, including essays and interviews, and extended the application period for the current vacancy by two weeks. The Council also agreed to extend the consideration date indefinitely for Neighborhood Advisory Committee representatives to the Multimodal Transportation Commission to resolve a potential conflict of interest. The meeting concluded with a unanimous motion to enter a closed session to discuss contract negotiations for real property acquisition.

Public comment was extensive on several items. Regarding the Historic Preservation Master Plan, a resident of the Montford Historic District and the Executive Director of the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County spoke in support, emphasizing preservation’s role in the city’s character. On the Haw Creek Commons project, public comment was divided. Opponents, including a Willowbrook Road resident and a Hawthorne Community Association board member, raised concerns about commercial uses in residential areas, safety, and property values, with one commenter describing the tiny houses as a "trailer park." Supporters, including a long-time church member and a United Methodist Church conference representative, highlighted the church’s history and the project’s community benefits. In response, a council member expressed concern that the ongoing production of tiny homes was a commercial use not seen in residential districts, while another stated they were "strongly supportive" of the proposal's opportunities for the community.

Regarding the preservation of 80–100-year-old oak trees at 11 Collier Avenue, multiple residents urged the Council to save the trees, citing their aesthetic and structural value. The Vice Mayor responded by stating, "I’m frankly not comfortable with the proposition that the city figure out how to fund all of it or 90% of it. This really needs to be a community effort." Another council member suggested that staff initiate communication with the developer to assess the willingness for a land swap or sale, stating, "From my perspective, for a council nod towards staff to saying we would like you to initiate communication with the developer... to see what's possible." Additionally, a representative from the Vietnam Veterans Association requested a donation to help reach their $25,000 budget for a traveling memorial wall exhibit, though no specific vote or member response regarding the donation was recorded.

Staff and Council members outlined several follow-up actions. Staff will initiate or build upon communication with the developer of the Collier Avenue property to determine the feasibility of a land swap or sale and will compile background information from the Parks Plan, Downtown Master Plan, and Economic Development CIP. The developer is expected to provide an appraisal of the property’s current market value in a couple of weeks. Staff will conduct open-format interviews for the TDA vacancy in October. The Simplicity presentation, delayed due to technical issues, will be presented on October 13.

These decisions impact residents by shaping the city’s physical landscape and economic development. The adoption of the Historic Preservation Master Plan and the approval of the Cat Café zoning reflect the Council’s focus on balancing growth with the preservation of Asheville’s unique character. The Haw Creek Commons approval allows for a mixed-use project that includes student housing and co-working spaces, while the restriction on ongoing tiny home production addresses concerns about commercial activity in residential zones. The ongoing dialogue regarding the Collier Avenue oaks highlights the tension between private development and community preservation, with the Council directing staff to explore potential partnerships with the developer rather than committing city funds immediately.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0afQ8iJifr0
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3167/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0afQ8iJifr0)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
