# City Council Meeting - June 9, 2015

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** June 9, 2015 11:00 AM EDT (2015-06-09T11:00:00-04:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5386/city-council-meeting-june-9-2015
**Outcome:** Council approved four zoning changes and 17 non-profit grants unanimously, but deferred the FY 2015-16 budget and EDC funding increase for later discussion.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on June 9, 2015, to address a range of legislative, financial, and land use matters. The meeting included recognitions for local institutions and veterans, a public hearing on the Fiscal Year 2015-16 Annual Operating Budget, and several zoning decisions. The Council also debated funding for the Economic Development Commission (EDC) and the allocation of affordable housing funds, while reviewing grants for non-profit organizations and making appointments to various city boards and commissions.

**Key Decisions and Votes**
The Council approved the Consent Agenda unanimously, excluding one item that was pulled for separate discussion. In the zoning docket, the Council unanimously approved four items: a rezoning at 1 Buffalo Street, conditional zoning for a 72-unit multifamily development at 29 Oak Hill Drive, an amendment to conditional zoning at 673 Sand Hill Road, and a technical amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) regarding sidewalk requirements. The Council also unanimously approved recommended grants for 17 non-profit organizations under the Strategic Partnership Fund and passed all motions to appoint or reappoint members to the Civil Service Board, African American Heritage Commission, Board of Electrical Examiners, Civic Center Commission, Downtown Commission, Historic Resources Commission, Multimodal Transportation Commission, Neighborhood Advisory Committee, Noise Ordinance Appeals Board, Public Art and Cultural Commission, and Recreation Board. Finally, the Council unanimously voted to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding a lawsuit involving Gannett Pacific Corp.

**Budget and Financial Discussions**
During the public hearing on the FY 2015-16 budget, Finance Director Barbara Whitehorn presented a balanced budget that includes a 1.5-cent ad valorem tax rate increase. Staff explained that drawing more than $700,000 from the fund balance would jeopardize the city’s AA bond rating, which is necessary for favorable interest rates on capital improvements. The Council debated the tax increase versus drawing from the fund balance but did not reach a final decision on the tax rate or the specific allocation of the $700,000 fund balance excess. One member proposed leaving the $700,000 in the fund balance and addressing allocation via a later budget amendment, an option staff confirmed was acceptable. The final adoption of the budget is scheduled for June 23, 2015.

In a separate discussion, the Council debated increasing the city’s annual contribution to the EDC from $60,000 to $100,000. A motion was made to increase the funding, but no final vote was recorded in the transcript as the discussion was ongoing. The debate centered on the EDC’s role in attracting major employers and its relationship with the Chamber of Commerce and Tourism Development Authority (TDA) regarding pending state legislation to increase the hotel occupancy tax. One Council member expressed disappointment that the Chamber and TDA leadership defined the occupancy tax as an expense rather than a partnership, stating, "I’m disappointed in the leadership of the Chamber and the tourism industry that they choose to define the occupancy tax as an expense to the tourism industry... I look to them as partners and sometimes that is questionable."

Regarding affordable housing, the Council discussed the allocation of $450,000 remaining in the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). Staff noted that leaving the funds in the CIP provided the most flexibility, stating, "The most flexible option as far as that money would be to leave it in the CIP because at this point it is just listed as affordable housing, from there it is completely up to council what happens to that money." The Council decided to leave the $450,000 in the Affordable Housing CIP rather than transferring it to the Trust Fund at this time, opting to wait for details on the Lee Walker Public Housing Complex redevelopment before final allocation. One Council member commented on the potential cost of the project, saying, "I’d almost like to sort of wait and see... I have a feeling it’s going to be a big number."

**Community Input**
Residents provided public comment during the budget hearing and other agenda items. A public commenter argued that friction between police and public housing residents is a budgetary issue stemming from competing for limited resources; no direct response was recorded. Another commenter criticized a $20 million budget increase from 2012-2015 and $12 million in salary increases, questioning the city’s commitment to the black community regarding Eagle Street housing demolition and labeling New Belgium incentives as "corporate welfare"; no direct response was recorded. A resident urged the City Manager not to raise ad valorem taxes or fees, citing surpluses in 2013-2014 and lack of CIP accountability; no direct response was recorded. A former seasonal temp urged the council to ensure all city employees receive a living wage, noting the current classification allows for abuse; no direct response was recorded. A representative from the Five Points Neighborhood Association requested increased funding for sidewalk repairs, new sidewalks, crosswalks, and traffic calming.

Regarding the EDC funding, a public commenter supported the existing $60,000 allocation, arguing EDC success was due to existing infrastructure and workforce. Council members disagreed, stating the EDC played a "vital and essential role" in attracting companies like GE Aviation. One member expressed disappointment that the Chamber/TDA defined the occupancy tax as an expense rather than a partnership but supported the increase to $100,000. A representative for the low-income community urged Council to consider the impact on low-income residents regarding Lee Walker redevelopment, stating, "You cannot exclude the low-income communities when making these decisions... We are Asheville." A Council member responded that the Housing, Community Development Committee would consider these insights at their next meeting and welcomed further input.

For the 29 Oak Hill Drive development, the applicant representative committed $5,000 toward traffic calming. A Greenway Committee representative requested consideration of the Greenway Master Plan for future developments near the railroad corridor, and a commenter argued reducing parking requirements encourages alternative transportation. The City Traffic Engineer responded that traffic calming on Oak Hill Drive is number three on the list, intended for completion by fall, and the $5,000 contribution could be added to the fund. Regarding the Strategic Partnership Fund, grant recipients and Blue Ridge Food Ventures thanked the Council for support. A low-income community representative asked Council to consider low-income residents in budget decisions. A Council member noted the grants represent a very small fraction of the overall budget, stating, "The whole request is about one in 400... one part in one four hundredth of the budget... These are very small numbers. This is pocket change."

**Follow-ups and Next Steps**
Staff agreed to several follow-up actions. The Community Development Manager will provide clear parameters for the additional $50,000 grant funding by Tuesday for review by the Housing, Community Development Committee at the next June meeting. The City Traffic Engineer will follow up with Council on the timing of the New Leicester Highway sidewalk project. Staff from Housing, Community Development will hold a meeting with Finance, Real Estate, and Community Development to discuss the flow of funds between the CIP and the Housing Trust Fund. The Council also agreed to revisit the EDC funding decision in the coming year to assess the impact of the increased funding.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Jzn9bFaIeE
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/3173/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Jzn9bFaIeE)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
