# City Council Meeting, December 9, 2014

**Body:** City of Asheville — City Council
**Date:** December 9, 2014 11:00 AM EST (2014-12-09T11:00:00-05:00)

**Link:** https://sunshinemeetings.org/event/5397/city-council-meeting-december-9-2014
**Outcome:** Council approved a density amendment and two multi-family developments, including the River Mills Loft, and continued two other apartment projects to January.

## Summary

The Asheville City Council convened on December 9, 2014, to address a full legislative agenda that included zoning amendments, development approvals, financial reports, and public safety matters. The meeting featured several public hearings regarding housing density and specific multi-family developments, as well as discussions on the city’s upcoming state legislative priorities and the search for a new Police Chief.

**Key Decisions and Votes**

The Council voted to continue two public hearing items to allow for further review: the Biltmore Apartments on Fairview Road was continued to January 27, 2015, and the Greymont Village Apartments were continued to January 13, 2015. Regarding the consent agenda, a motion was made to approve the routine items, including contracts and expenditures, but the transcript summary does not record a final vote outcome for this specific motion. The Council did vote to accept the Fiscal Year 2014 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR), which passed. The first-quarter financial report was presented for information only, with no vote taken.

In zoning and development matters, the Council approved a revised amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) that increases residential density in 11 commercial/mixed-use districts and decreases it in one industrial district. The Council also voted to approve the permanent closure of a portion of Westover Alley. For the White Oak Grove Apartments project, the Council voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the conditional zoning request, subject to specific conditions including notice to tenants regarding private road access. Additionally, the Council voted unanimously to approve the conditional use permit for the River Mills Loft development, a 254-unit residential project. This approval included conditions requiring the developer to complete the city’s “Luigi” affordable housing incentive application, with 7% of units designated as affordable at 80% of Area Median Income (AMI) and 85% as workforce housing between 80% and 120% of AMI. The Council also voted unanimously to adopt its legislative agenda for the upcoming state session, focusing on sales tax reform and transportation funding.

**Discussion Highlights**

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to public hearings on housing. During the density amendment hearing, staff presented the goal of encouraging multi-family development near downtown and transit corridors to address affordable housing shortages. A Council member highlighted that 31% of Asheville workers make less than $25,000 per year and 47% of rental households are cost-burdened, emphasizing the policy’s aim to ensure socio-economic diversity.

For the River Mills Loft project, discussions covered floodplain management, traffic impacts, and open space requirements. A Council member expressed concern about the traffic impact, stating, "I think we heard pretty clearly tonight that... it would be in your interest to begin to develop a relationship with these folks that are going to be your neighbors for the future here." The member encouraged developers to build a positive relationship with the neighborhood. Regarding the White Oak Grove project, the City Attorney clarified that in conditional zoning cases, conditions must be mutually consented to by the applicant, meaning the Council could not impose certain conditions if the developer did not agree.

**Community Input**

Public comment was extensive across several agenda items. On the density amendment, a piano teacher from West Asheville expressed concern that the median income listed in city documents does not reflect the reality of many residents, noting that most people she works with earn half that amount. A resident from East/West Asheville called the plan a "great first step" to consolidate apartments along corridors.

Regarding the White Oak Grove Apartments, comments were mixed. Supporters highlighted the inclusion of bus passes, a community garden, and energy-efficient materials. Opponents raised concerns about traffic, specifically a private road crossing a nearby dealership’s property, and the lack of infrastructure on Hazel Mill Road. One resident requested sidewalks and traffic calming measures, while another challenged the affordability of the proposed rents compared to the city’s living wage ordinance. A representative for a nearby car dealership requested written disclosure to residents that a private road is not to be utilized as a public access route.

For the River Mills Loft, multiple residents expressed concern about traffic volume and the lack of sidewalks on Thompson Street and Stoner Road. One resident stated, "We don't have sidewalks... it's dangerous... I just wish... the developer had considered the community." Another resident urged the developer to engage directly with neighbors, noting that the legal notice radius was insufficient for a project of this scale. A member of the Asheville Parks and Greenways Foundation requested that the council consider a 20% affordable housing goal from a 2008 task force study, noting the current proposal only offered 7%.

On the Police Chief search, a public commenter urged the Council to weigh heavily the hiring of another African American Chief to address past issues of racism. Another commenter asked that the Council require new candidates to "embrace and endorse community policing." No Council member responded directly to these specific comments in the transcript. A representative from Food and Water Watch urged the Council to pass a resolution supporting federal legislation to ban the routine use of antibiotics in non-sick livestock; no Council member responded directly to this comment.

**Follow-ups**

Staff agreed to work on a format to report wage information for contracts on the consent agenda, checking current practices to determine what additional information could be gathered. Staff also agreed to provide details, specs, and photographs of the proposed seating for McCormick Field before the City executes the purchase authorization. The City Manager was directed to investigate funding priority for Hazel Mill sidewalks in the upcoming Capital Improvement Plan. Staff confirmed they can conduct a specific traffic study on Hazel Mill Road to determine if lowering the speed limit or adding traffic calming measures is feasible. The developer for River Mills Loft confirmed that the “Luigi” application is already in the system. Staff and council members agreed to work closely with the state DOT to ensure planned improvements to Swannanoa River Road include pedestrian and bicycle activation. The Chair stated that Councilman Pelley and the Chair would travel to Raleigh the following day to the League of Municipalities annual legislative agenda setting meeting.

**Impact**

These decisions directly affect housing availability and neighborhood infrastructure in Asheville. The approval of the density amendment and the two large multi-family developments (White Oak Grove and River Mills Loft) will add significant housing stock, including units designated as affordable or workforce housing, to the city. The conditions attached to these approvals, such as the completion of the “Luigi” application and specific setback requirements, aim to mitigate potential negative impacts on surrounding neighborhoods. The legislative agenda resolution signals the city’s intent to advocate for state-level changes in sales tax and transportation funding, which could influence future local revenue and infrastructure projects.

## Video & Transcript

- Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QGXfPALyns8
- Transcript: https://sunshinemeetings.org/transcript/2599/segments

## Sources

- [YouTube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QGXfPALyns8)
- [City Council agenda page](https://www.ashevillenc.gov/government/city-council-agenda/)
