Board of Elections Candidate Challenge Hearing

Board of Elections Candidate Challenge Hearing Recap: Sheriff Candidate Eligibility Under Review

On January 20, 2026, the Buncombe County Board of Elections convened a hearing to address a challenge to Victor L. Mormon’s candidacy for Sheriff in the Republican primary election. The hearing, open to the public, centered on a legal challenge filed by citizen Tina Lunsford, who argued that Mr. Mormon’s recent switch from Democratic to Republican party affiliation – less than 90 days prior to filing his candidacy – violates state law. This challenge directly impacts the upcoming Republican primary election and the potential field of candidates vying for Sheriff.

The hearing followed a formal legal process, allowing both Ms. Lunsford (the challenger) and Mr. Mormon (the challenged candidate) to present their cases. Ms. Lunsford’s challenge focused on demonstrating that Mr. Mormon hadn't met the 90-day party affiliation requirement stipulated by North Carolina law, presenting records from the Board of Elections and Georgia voter registration data. Mr. Mormon countered with documentation including his voter registration records, a party affiliation reference sheet, and forms from the Sheriff’s Standards Division. Notably, Ms. Lunsford also called Heather Boyd as a witness who presented public records and affidavits related to Mr. Mormon’s residency, including details surrounding a homestead exemption in Fulton County, Georgia. A key point of debate during the hearing involved the admissibility of certain evidence, particularly news articles and opinion pieces, with the Board carefully navigating rules of evidence to ensure a fair process.

Significant discussion revolved around establishing precise dates and verifying records to determine if Mr. Mormon met the 90-day party affiliation deadline. The Board also scrutinized information related to Mr. Mormon’s residency in Fulton County, Georgia, specifically the homestead exemption and its subsequent cancellation, raising questions about his eligibility to run as a Republican candidate in Buncombe County. The hearing highlighted the importance of accurate record-keeping and adherence to state election laws, underscoring the Board’s commitment to upholding these regulations.

While the hearing provided a platform for both sides to present their arguments and evidence, no final decision was reached during the session. The Board deliberated but adjourned before a formal vote could be taken. Importantly, citizens can expect an official order from the Board of Elections within 20 days outlining their decision regarding Mr. Mormon’s candidacy. This order will definitively state whether his name remains on the Republican primary ballot or if the challenge was successful. Residents interested in following this case are encouraged to monitor the Board of Elections website for updates and access to the final order.