Historic Resources Commission – September 11, 2024

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap – September 11, 2024

The Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on September 11, 2024, to review applications impacting historic properties within Asheville’s designated districts. The meeting, led by Chair Sue Oliva, focused primarily on assessing proposed alterations, demolitions, and new construction projects, ensuring alignment with preservation guidelines. All commissioners were present and introduced themselves, highlighting their diverse expertise in fields like interior design, history, and archeology. The minutes from the July meeting were approved as a standard procedural step.

A significant portion of the meeting centered on three key agenda items. First, the HRC reviewed plans for a new structure at 30 Grind Staff in the St. Dunstan’s Historic District. While acknowledging the project's potential, commissioners raised concerns regarding its impact on a mature white oak tree and the proposed use of shake siding and a fiberglass front door. Ultimately, the commission approved the project contingent upon revised landscaping plans (including tree replacement), clarification of material specifications, and reconciliation between submitted drawings and detailed specifications. Secondly, the commission addressed an after-the-fact review concerning property at 153 Cumberland Avenue, owned by Steve and Kevin. Recognizing the unique challenges posed by limited parking options, commissioners appreciated their efforts to improve the property and approved changes made to the driveway, front entry steps, retaining wall with railing, and gravel area. Approvals were granted with conditions requiring a gravel driveway apron, replacement of wood edging with metal, and painting the front entry steps to match existing trim. Finally, a similar after-the-fact review was conducted for 8 Birch Street, involving modifications to the driveway, front entry landing, retaining wall with railing and stairway. Discussions focused on material appropriateness (concrete versus brick) and the design of the stairway, ultimately leading to approval with conditions requiring a gravel driveway and painting the wood steps and railing.

Public comment was limited, but those who spoke largely expressed support for the changes made at Steve and Kevin’s property. Throughout the discussions, commissioners emphasized the importance of accurate grading plans to prevent future enforcement issues and acknowledged Steve and Kevin's positive contribution to their neighborhood. A notable announcement was made regarding the HRC’s successful application for a CLG grant, which will fund an educational series.

Looking ahead, the applicants for 30 Grind Staff and 8 Birch Street are required to submit revised plans addressing the conditions outlined by the commission. HRC staff will follow up with these applicants to ensure compliance. The Commission also announced a virtual work session dedicated to discussing the Montford Standards, and will continue exploring options for implementation. Finally, the HRC formally approved a National Register nomination for Hopkins Chapel AME Zion Church, recognizing its significant role as an African-American church and architectural landmark.

For those seeking more detailed information, the full meeting transcript and associated documents will be available on the City of Asheville’s website (link forthcoming). Residents are encouraged to contact the Historic Resources Commission staff directly with any questions or concerns.