Urban Forestry Commission – August 2, 2024

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: Protecting Asheville’s Trees – August 2, 2024

On August 2nd, the Urban Forestry Commission convened a special meeting to address critical updates concerning tree preservation and urban forestry within Asheville. Originally slated for City Council Chambers, the meeting was relocated due to unforeseen repairs, a change acknowledged and navigated effectively by city staff. This recap provides an overview of the discussions, decisions, and next steps for residents interested in learning more about how our city is working to protect its valuable tree canopy.

A significant portion of the meeting focused on proposed revisions to two key ordinances: Chapter 7, Article 19 (Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance) and Chapter 20 (Heritage Trees). Commissioners unanimously approved staff recommendations to amend Chapter 7, Article 19. These changes aim to modernize and strengthen tree preservation efforts by expanding when canopy preservation requirements apply to development projects, introducing a more accurate method for measuring tree canopy (direct measurement), streamlining the permit process for tree removals, and clarifying existing regulations. Essentially, these updates will provide a clearer framework for protecting trees during development projects and ensuring consistent application of preservation efforts.

Discussion surrounding Chapter 20, which deals with designating "heritage trees" on city property, was less conclusive. Keith Aiken, the City Urban Forester, began presenting proposed changes that would establish criteria for identifying and protecting these significant trees, potentially offering incentives for their preservation. However, due to time constraints and a packed agenda, the presentation was not fully completed. Several members of the public offered valuable input during the public comment period, including Kathy Walsh from Blue Ridge Audubon who highlighted successful tree master programs in other cities and encouraged Asheville to explore similar initiatives. Concerns were also raised by Sharon Summerall regarding potential impacts of building regulations on tree preservation, and Steve Rasmussen emphasized the importance of data-driven decision making. Jared Wheatley brought up concerns about displacement, community partnerships, and unintended consequences of regulations.

Beyond the specific ordinances, a recurring theme throughout the meeting was the need for improved communication and transparency. Commissioners expressed a desire to accelerate progress on these important initiatives, recognizing the urgency of addressing tree preservation concerns. The importance of engaging with and listening to community voices was repeatedly emphasized, highlighting a commitment to collaborative decision-making.

What's Next?

The Commission has outlined several key action items moving forward:

• Chapter 20 Strategy: City staff, led by Stephanie Munson-Dahl, will develop a detailed strategy for advancing updates to Chapter 20. This plan will be shared with the Commission and open for feedback before any further action is taken, ensuring a collaborative approach.
• Data Tracking and Reporting: The Commission will explore ways to track and regularly report data on tree removals, providing a clearer picture of the city’s overall tree canopy health.
• Continued Ordinance Updates: The Commission remains committed to updating its ordinances and will continue working towards these goals, prioritizing public engagement and collaboration.

This meeting underscored the Urban Forestry Commission’s dedication to safeguarding Asheville's urban forest. While challenges remain, the discussions highlighted a shared commitment to balancing development with responsible tree preservation and ensuring that community voices are heard throughout the process. Residents can expect to see further developments as staff works on a strategy for Chapter 20 and continues efforts to refine existing ordinances.