Historic Resources Commission – June 12, 2024

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap – June 12, 2024

The Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on June 12, 2024, for a comprehensive meeting addressing proposed changes to historic properties and considering landmark designations. The HRC, comprised of architects, historians, a real estate broker, and legal advisor, serves as a quasi-judicial body responsible for evaluating proposals within Asheville’s designated historic districts based on established guidelines and standards. This recap summarizes the key discussions, decisions, and next steps for residents interested in understanding these preservation efforts.

A significant portion of the meeting centered on a proposal concerning an accessory structure at 20 Watauga Street. This item, previously discussed in prior meetings, involved a plan for a new garage/secondary building within the alleyway. Commissioners raised concerns about the proposed structure's scale, noting it appeared larger than typical accessory buildings in the surrounding neighborhood. Following revisions from the applicant – notably, removing a breezeway and finalizing material choices including fiber cement shake siding and a brick chimney – the HRC ultimately voted to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness with no conditions. While acknowledging initial scale concerns, commissioners determined that the revised design and materials were compatible with the historic character of the area.

The meeting also featured a new business item focused on designating the historic F.W. Woolworth Building (25 Haywood Street) as a local landmark. Recognizing the building's architectural significance – showcasing Art Deco design – its role in downtown Asheville’s commercial development, and its importance as a site of civil rights demonstrations, the HRC unanimously voted to recommend that Asheville City Council adopt an ordinance formally designating it as a landmark. This recommendation will now be forwarded to City Council for final approval, marking a significant step in preserving this vital piece of Asheville’s history. The North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) had previously offered supportive comments on the proposal, further bolstering its case.

Beyond these major items, the HRC addressed several other proposals and announcements. A proposal to replace a missing porch railing at 174 West Chestnut Street with turned balusters was approved, contingent upon staff review and approval of the roof color. The commission also voted to donate a cup previously awarded by the HRC and some bricks from the Vance Monument to Buncombe County Special Collections for archival purposes. Looking ahead, the HRC discussed plans to apply for a grant to conduct an education series aimed at educating city leadership and the broader community about historic preservation. Finally, the meeting concluded with recognition of departing commissioners Xander Ellenbogan and Maria De Sassi for their service.

For Asheville residents, this meeting highlighted the HRC’s crucial role in safeguarding the city's historic character. The decisions regarding 20 Watauga Street and the Woolworth Building demonstrate a commitment to balancing development with preservation. The ongoing exploration of an education series underscores the HRC’s dedication to fostering a greater understanding and appreciation for historic preservation within the community. Residents can expect further action on the Woolworth Building designation as it moves to City Council, and should stay informed about future HRC meetings for updates on preservation efforts throughout Asheville.