Environment & Safety Committee – May 20, 2024

Environment & Safety Committee Meeting Recap – May 20, 2024

The Asheville City Council Environment & Safety Committee convened virtually on May 20, 2024, focusing primarily on the recommendations of the Noise Advisory Board (NAB) regarding noise policy adjustments. The meeting, which was attended by committee members and city staff including Development Services Division Director Mark Bethany and City Manager Deborah Campbell, centered on evaluating the effectiveness of current noise ordinances and exploring potential improvements to address ongoing community concerns. Due to technical issues, public comments were collected via email and will be reviewed separately.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to discussing the NAB’s findings and proposals. The board expressed concern that despite recent revisions, complaint numbers regarding noise haven't decreased year-over-year. Specific challenges highlighted included persistent issues with vehicular noise, such as engine revving and modified exhaust systems, prompting a discussion on potential solutions like increased signage or greater involvement from the Asheville Police Department (APD). The NAB also advocated for expanding board representation to include a member with public health expertise and designating an at-large position representing multifamily housing residents. Further recommendations included moderating construction hours on Saturdays in residential zones, potentially shifting the start time to 6 a.m., and adding restrictions on the use of high-noise power equipment during nighttime hours.

The committee also received an update from city staff on noise compliance efforts and identified areas for ordinance clarification. Specifically, definitions within commercial and industrial zones need refinement, and regulations regarding pressure washing and generators require further attention. Staff also noted that the city's participation in the National Community Survey revealed that roughly one-third of residents consider noise an “essential or very important” issue, underscoring the significance of addressing these concerns.

The committee took one formal vote: unanimously approving the minutes from their April 23, 2024 meeting via roll call. No other votes were taken during the session.

Looking ahead, the NAB’s recommendations will be incorporated into the city's upcoming organizational work plan. City staff will assess the feasibility of integrating these suggestions into future ordinance changes, taking workload and priorities into consideration. Committee Chair Maggie Ullman emphasized the importance of considering broader context and potential impacts when evaluating any ordinance adjustments, a sentiment echoed by Jessica Thomason from the NAB who highlighted their desire to find impactful solutions. Residents can expect an update on these efforts in June or July, potentially including a discussion of proposed ordinance changes. The committee will also revisit the solicitation ordinance update in June and review the Municipal Climate Action Plan & Stormwater Master Plan.

This meeting’s outcomes are important for Asheville residents as they directly impact the quality of life within our community. Addressing noise concerns, particularly those related to vehicular traffic and construction activities, will contribute to a more peaceful and enjoyable environment for all. The committee's consideration of the NAB’s recommendations, along with ongoing staff review and potential ordinance revisions, demonstrates a commitment to responding to resident feedback and improving the effectiveness of existing regulations.