Downtown Commission – April 26, 2024

Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: Proposed Business Improvement District Sparks Debate

On April 26, 2024, the Asheville Downtown Commission convened to discuss a significant proposal: establishing a Downtown Business Improvement District (BID). This meeting, attended by Commissioners and open to the public, centered on a plan spearheaded by the Chamber of Commerce (representing a steering committee) aimed at enhancing downtown Asheville through a dedicated funding mechanism. The discussion was lively, with robust public comment and Commissioners raising important questions about the proposal’s potential impact.

The core of the discussion revolved around the proposed BID, designed to provide "enhanced safety and hospitality" through services like increased cleaning, security measures, and potentially other improvements. The Chamber of Commerce presented an updated version of their proposal, incorporating feedback from City Council. Key adjustments included removing four residences and a church from the proposed BID area on Hildebrand Street, adding a 15th seat to the BID board for a representative from the Community Council (a partnership roundtable of non-profits, business associations, and community groups), and refining tax value thresholds for different property owner categories. While Commissioners acknowledged the potential benefits, a significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to exploring concerns surrounding accountability and transparency within the BID’s operations, as well as clarifying City Council's ultimate authority in approving and potentially amending the BID annually. Commissioner Hayden Plemons recused herself from the discussion due to her potential involvement with the Asheville Downtown Association. Notably, no formal vote was taken on the BID proposal itself, reflecting a need for further consideration and clarification.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to public comment, with a considerable number of citizens sharing their perspectives. While some speakers expressed support for the BID, citing its potential to improve downtown cleanliness and safety, many voiced concerns. These included worries about the rushed nature of the process and a perceived lack of adequate community engagement, as well as fears that the BID could contribute to gentrification and displacement within the downtown area. Several speakers questioned the power dynamics inherent in a privately-controlled entity managing public funds, and raised concerns about how "clean and safe" would be defined, particularly regarding potential impacts on marginalized communities. Alternative funding models and community-led initiatives were also suggested as viable alternatives to a BID.

Following the meeting, several key action items have been identified. The proposed BID will now be taken up by Asheville City Council for further discussion and a potential vote in May and June. Should the council approve the BID, a Request for Proposals (RFP) will be issued to solicit management organizations. Commissioners emphasized the importance of more robust community input throughout this process, particularly regarding the RFP and the BID’s operational details. The Chamber of Commerce and the BID steering committee will continue to work with City Council, incorporating feedback received from both Commissioners and the public.

Ultimately, this meeting highlighted a complex debate surrounding the future of downtown Asheville. While there’s recognition for the need to enhance services and improve the area, concerns remain about ensuring equitable outcomes, transparency, and meaningful community involvement. Residents should stay informed as the proposal moves forward through City Council, where their voices will continue to play a crucial role in shaping downtown’s future. For more information, visit the City of Asheville website (https://www.ashevillenc.gov/) and the Asheville Downtown Association website (https://www.downtownasheville.com/).