Historic Resources Commission – April 10, 2024

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap – April 10, 2024

The Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on April 10, 2024, to discuss a range of topics related to historic preservation within the city. The HRC is a key body responsible for reviewing projects impacting designated historic districts and landmarks, ensuring that alterations and new construction respect the character of these special areas. This meeting included discussions on specific project reviews, potential updates to district standards, and the ongoing process of designating a significant landmark.

A primary focus of the meeting was reviewing requests for Certificates of Appropriateness (COAs). The commission approved a request concerning 112 Pearson Drive, allowing alterations to the non-contributing structure with conditions. While approving replacements for doors and roofing, they rejected a proposal to paint the brick, upholding existing standards against such changes. Similarly, a COA was approved for 450 Montfort Avenue, granting permission to convert an existing carriage house into a residential unit, also with conditions requiring submission of manufacturer specifications. These decisions highlight the HRC's commitment to balancing preservation guidelines with individual property needs.

Beyond project-specific reviews, a significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to discussing potential amendments to the Montford Historic District Standards. A resident-led group presented proposals aimed at modernizing these standards to better address contemporary concerns while respecting the district’s historic character. Key points of discussion included allowing front yard fences for safety, permitting additions to existing structures (such as side or wraparound additions), and facilitating sustainable improvements like solar panels and energy-efficient window/door replacements (with wood frames). The commission recognized the importance of these considerations, acknowledging a need to adapt preservation practices to evolving community needs. Following presentations and discussion, the HRC agreed to form a subcommittee – likely within the existing Executive Committee - to further explore these proposed changes in partnership with the Montford neighborhood.

Community input played a vital role throughout the meeting. Several residents shared their perspectives during public comment periods, passionately advocating for changes to address safety concerns (particularly regarding fences and pedestrian traffic) while emphasizing the importance of maintaining a vibrant neighborhood. A window specialist also offered valuable insights, advocating for historic window restoration over replacement to maximize energy efficiency and reduce environmental impact.

Looking ahead, the HRC has several key action items. They will work closely with the Montford Neighborhood Association (MNA) and the group proposing standards amendments to foster communication and collaboration. The commission will also continue its review of the Woolworth building’s landmark designation, including a public hearing scheduled for June. The formation of the subcommittee to review Montford district standards signifies a commitment to a comprehensive and collaborative approach to updating design guidelines, recognizing the need for careful consideration given limited resources. Ultimately, these ongoing efforts demonstrate the HRC’s dedication to preserving Asheville's unique historic character while ensuring that these areas remain vibrant and adaptable for current and future residents.