Special Meeting: Historic Resources Commission (Virtual) (Apr 28, 2026)

Recap of April 28, 2026 Historic Resources Commission Meeting: Montford Design Standards Review

On April 28, 2026, the Buncombe County Historic Resources Commission (HRC) Executive Committee held a virtual work session focused on proposed changes to the Montford Historic District Design Standards. This meeting, part of a review process spanning nearly two years, aimed to refine recommendations for the full HRC commission regarding resident-submitted amendments. While no formal votes were taken, this session provided valuable insight into the direction of these potential changes and their impact on Montford residents.

The primary focus of the meeting was a deep dive into several key areas within the design standards, including clarifying language related to the National Register nomination (Page 11), guidelines for fences in front yards, and revisions concerning additions to historic homes. A significant portion of the discussion centered on fences, with commissioners grappling with how to balance community desires for privacy and aesthetic preferences with the need to preserve Montford’s historic character. Concerns were raised about subjectivity in a “case-by-case” review process, prompting suggestions for more clearly defined criteria or the creation of a subcommittee to further explore this complex issue. Discussions regarding additions focused on ensuring that any new construction remains subordinate to existing structures and complements the historic features of Montford homes.

Community input played a crucial role in shaping the discussion. Rob Mays, a resident and attorney, voiced strong concerns about the amendment process itself, questioning its transparency and expressing disappointment with the proposed changes, particularly regarding fence guidelines. He argued that the recent community survey wasn't adequately considered in the recommendations. Other commissioners emphasized the importance of finding a balance between community desires and preserving Montford's unique historic character. Leslie Humphrey, a construction company owner and resident, offered a practical suggestion: developing a clear rubric for case-by-case fence decisions to promote consistency and fairness.

Looking ahead, the Executive Committee will schedule a follow-up meeting to finalize its recommendations before presenting them to the full HRC commission. The crucial next step for residents is the public hearing and vote scheduled for May 13, 2026, where they will have the opportunity to provide public comment and directly influence the final decision. The full HRC is considering splitting the vote, allowing for separate consideration of fence guidelines and addition guidelines. Staff will also update a project page with timeline information to keep the community informed throughout this process.

This ongoing review of the Montford Historic District Design Standards represents a significant effort to clarify and refine guidelines that shape the appearance of one of Asheville’s most treasured neighborhoods. While the process has been complex, involving diverse opinions and ongoing debate, it underscores the HRC’s commitment to preserving Montford's historic character while addressing contemporary needs. Residents are encouraged to actively engage in the process by attending the May 13th meeting and sharing their perspectives.