Historic Resources Commission (In-Person) (Jan 14, 2026)

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: January 14, 2026

On January 14, 2026, the Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened a meeting at Asheville City Hall to address several Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) requests and other matters related to preserving the historic character of Asheville and Buncombe County. The meeting, attended by commissioners and staff, focused primarily on proposed construction projects within the Montford Historic District.

A significant portion of the meeting centered around a proposal to replace retaining walls at both Riverside Cemetery and Montford Park. Commissioners engaged in detailed discussions regarding appropriate materials and construction techniques, emphasizing the importance of replicating historic masonry aesthetics. Concerns were raised about the visual impact of modern construction methods, such as sheet piles, and the potential for veneer materials to fall short of historic standards. Following a robust debate about options including salvaged stone, concrete walls with stacked and tied stones, and sheet piles, the commission voted unanimously to grant a continuance, effectively delaying any immediate action on this project. The applicant is now required to resubmit revised plans by Wednesday, incorporating new veneer options, with a future hearing scheduled for February. Commissioner Scobie suggested reviewing previously approved projects within the district featuring newer walls as a reference point for the applicant.

Beyond the retaining wall discussion, the HRC also considered COA requests for window replacements at 255 Cumberland Avenue and construction of an accessory structure at 123 West Chestnut Street. Staff recommended approval for both projects, contingent on the applicant addressing minor outstanding information requests. For 255 Cumberland Avenue, this includes providing details on the number of divided lites in the windows and confirming that new trim will match existing historic elements. Regarding 123 West Chestnut Street, the applicant must provide a perspective rendering from the southwest, manufacturer specifications for the south-facing door, and dimensions of the retaining wall. The commission also discussed fencing replacement material for 53 Birch Street, which is part of the same application.

While no formal public comments were recorded in the transcript, commissioners demonstrated a clear commitment to upholding the Montford Historic District Design Review Standards and minimizing disruption to adjacent properties. The commission chair will also clarify the scope of a planned presentation to the Montford Neighborhood Association regarding guideline amendments.

What's Next?

• The applicant for the retaining wall project at Riverside Cemetery and Montford Park must resubmit revised plans by Wednesday.
• The applicant for 123 West Chestnut Street must provide the requested additional information.
• A future hearing regarding the retaining wall project is scheduled for February (date to be determined).
• The commission chair will coordinate with staff and the Montford Neighborhood Association regarding a presentation on guideline amendments.

This meeting underscored the HRC’s dedication to balancing preservation efforts with practical construction needs within historic areas. The commission's decision to grant a continuance reflects their commitment to ensuring that any changes made to historic properties are sensitive to the district’s unique character and comply with established design guidelines. Residents can expect further updates on these projects as they progress through the review process.