LIVE @ Asheville Citizens Police Advisory Committee Meeting (CPAC) 11/6/19

Asheville CPAC Meeting Recap: Focus on Consent Searches, Community Collaboration & Public Safety Concerns (November 6, 2019)

The Asheville Citizens Police Advisory Committee (CPAC) held a unique meeting on November 6, 2019, focused primarily on providing updates and facilitating community discussion regarding the Asheville Police Department's (APD) new consent search policy. While unable to formally conduct business due to unforeseen circumstances, the meeting provided valuable insights into current policing practices and fostered important dialogue between APD leadership and residents.

A significant portion of the meeting centered on a detailed explanation of the recently implemented consent search policy. Police Commander Eric Hudak walked attendees through the process, emphasizing that officers are now required to clearly explain what "consent" means before initiating a search. Crucially, verbal consent must be recorded (typically via body camera) and individuals have the right to refuse consent without facing any repercussions. If an officer develops "probable cause" – reasonable grounds to believe a crime has been, is being or will be committed – after obtaining consent, the person can withdraw their consent. However, if probable cause is established before consent is given, the search can proceed. This clarification aims to ensure transparency and protect individual rights during police encounters.

Beyond the consent search policy, discussions touched on broader themes of community policing and building trust between law enforcement and Asheville residents. Chief Hudak emphasized his philosophy, viewing himself as the "chief of the community" and prioritizing service to both the police department and the public. He also discussed his role in the upcoming selection process for a new Police Chief, highlighting the importance of community involvement. Crime statistics were presented, revealing increases in burglaries, assaults, and theft in certain areas like West Asheville and Tunnel Road, alongside a concerning cluster of violent incidents around Seattle’s. The committee also explored potential collaboration with the Human Relations Commission (HRC), a topic that resonated strongly throughout the meeting.

Community voices were central to the discussion, with several residents sharing their concerns and perspectives. One resident raised anxieties about a recent shooting and potential hate group activity, particularly impacting the LGBTQ+ community. Another pointed out a concerning trend: while police funding has increased, vital social services for individuals struggling with mental health and substance use are dwindling. These comments underscored a recurring theme: the need for a holistic approach to public safety that addresses underlying social issues alongside traditional policing methods.

Key Decisions & Actions:

• The CPAC voted to formally collaborate with the Human Relations Commission (HRC) through a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), solidifying their partnership.
• The APD will host additional community meetings to specifically discuss the consent search policy and its impact.
• CPAC members will begin working on their annual report, utilizing a provided rubric for guidance.
• A working group or subcommittee will be established to coordinate efforts with the HRC, further strengthening their collaborative relationship.

What's Next & Why It Matters:

The CPAC’s focus on data transparency and community engagement signals a commitment to greater accountability in policing practices. Residents can expect further opportunities to provide feedback and participate in discussions about these important issues. The collaboration with the Human Relations Commission promises a broader, more inclusive approach to addressing public safety concerns and fostering positive relationships between the police department and the community. The ongoing dialogue about consent searches, coupled with concerns raised by residents regarding social services and vulnerable populations, highlights the need for a comprehensive strategy that prioritizes both law enforcement effectiveness and community well-being. Citizens are encouraged to stay informed, attend future meetings, and share their concerns with the CPAC.

This recap aims to provide a clear understanding of the key discussions and outcomes from this CPAC meeting, ensuring that Asheville residents are well-informed about ongoing efforts to improve community policing and address public safety challenges.