Study Areas Covered by Prismatic
FY26 Joint Meeting with Schools and County Budget Retreat | January 16, 2025 · January 16, 2025 at 9:00 AM
The board noted the study areas presented by Prismatic, which encompassed the following key areas: Governance, Policy, and Procedures; Educational Outcomes; Student Well-being; Instructional and Programmatic Offerings; Student Enrollment; Facilities; Business Operations and Fiscal Impacts; Management, Personnel, and Communications; Child Nutrition; Transportation.
Documents
- 9487.pdfReport · PDF · 70 pages
What was said
In about 30 minutes or so, I set the timer, otherwise I am likely to ramble on forever. But in that 30 minutes, I'm going to try to share as much as I can about what we have learned on this journey since embarking on this study February, March into April time frame. First, a little bit about the project. What you see on the screen is the text of the legislative mandate that created this current consolidation study for Asheville-Bunkham. This is the text from House Bill 142, signed into law by the governor at the end of September in 2023. I'd like to point out two things with this. One is the use of the word "shall." at this point in presentations is when I talk about how the governing body volunteered to do this work the staff were voluntold in this case that's not true everyone in this room was voluntold to provide this work and that said even so we received tremendous cooperation from ACS BCS and the county in completing this work and we're very appreciative of that the other words I'd like to point out are including the potential economic and educational impact. The mandate does not prescribe how the study is to be done. It does not provide the framework. Specifically it doesn't say you know which counts for more economic impact or educational impact. Left unsaid. So a little bit about how do we go about this project. First we assemble a team of great consultants. We North Carolina school systems all of whom have been associated with worked in or consulting for school districts state agencies over the course of their careers within the team that you see on the left side of the slide we devoted three personnel to the finance aspects this was a tricky project in terms of how the finances might shake out with consolidation without consolidation and looking at the current financial status of each one of the systems we then had a consultant over each of the various functional areas outlined within the RFP. On the right they were supported by a team of analysts, technical personnel, from most of them from our office in Charlotte. At this point I'd like to point out that one of the hallmarks of prismatics projects is our adherence to seven key values, one of which is being bold. We aren't interested in supporting the status quo unless the status quo is achieving extraordinary student outcomes and over the years various prismatic consultants have been on teams that have recommended bold things such as closing 39 of Houston's 280 schools we made that recommendation in 2019 we've recommended top to bottom reorganizations of many central office structures we've recommended the elimination of literally thousands of unnecessary positions across our 300 plus projects and in our work as consultants before that. One statewide study where I worked on years and years ago, we made bold recommendations that literally led to death threats. And I'm not saying this to make the work sound glamorous because it decidedly is not glamorous. I am making the point to detail and to underscore the value that prismatic places on making bold recommendations and to help provide a a proper background to frame our ultimate recommendation on this study. This slide provides the RFP areas that we were to review. You can see they cover really soup to nuts within a school system, everything from governance, the school board, policies and procedures, how we play the game, all the way down through facilities, business operations, child nutrition, and transportation. So how did we frame this project in the absence of a legislative mandate that said do it like this? We went to the literature And developed a framework in developing that framework. We looked at a couple of key things