PBOA Regular Meeting
June 4, 2024 at 6:08 PM
- 1 h 18 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Town of Woodfin Planning Board of Adjustment (PBOA) held a regular meeting on June 4, 2024. The session addressed the approval of previous minutes, public comment procedures, and two evidentiary public hearings for zoning variances. The Board also continued a legislative public hearing regarding a text amendment to the Town’s zoning code.
Key Decisions The Board voted 6-0 to approve the agenda and the minutes from the meetings held on March 5, 2024, and April 2, 2024. Regarding the administrative review for a preliminary plat for a 6-lot major subdivision at 90 Jonestown Road and 99999 Crestfield Road, the application was withdrawn from the agenda.
In the evidentiary public hearings, the Board voted 5-0 to approve a variance request for the property at 66 Lake Town Lane. This variance allows a retaining wall to be constructed at a height of 20 feet 6 inches, exceeding the standard 12-foot limit in the R-7 Residential District. The approval is subject to the condition that the retaining wall be stained a natural grayish-brownish color to blend with the surrounding mountain landscape. Additionally, the variance will become null and void if the shed on the property is ever removed.
The Board also voted 5-0 to approve a variance request for the property at 15 Elk Mountain Road. This variance reduces the required screening buffer strip from 10 feet to 1 foot for a property zoned Community Shopping. The approval includes conditions that the existing shed must match the house and that the variance is null and void if the shed is demolished.
Discussion Highlights The primary focus of the meeting was the variance request for 66 Lake Town Lane, where the applicant, Greg Cloos, presented on behalf of the property owner, Lake Town Lane Revocable Trust. Cloos argued that the taller retaining wall was necessary for construction on the steeply sloped property and would minimize disturbance. Staff member Ricky Hurley provided a detailed explanation of the property’s topography, sewer lines, and proposed landscaping. The Board found that strict application of the regulation would cause unnecessary hardship due to the property's topography and shape.
For the 15 Elk Mountain Road variance, the applicant, Larry Scott, represented WAGB, LLC. The request involved converting a former parsonage into an office while retaining an existing non-conforming accessory structure (a shed) that encroaches on the required buffer strip. Staff noted that compliance with the full buffer requirement would require demolishing the existing structure, leading the Board to find that strict application would cause unnecessary hardship due to the property's peculiar conditions.
During the public comment segment, the Board clarified procedures, emphasizing that individuals must demonstrate "standing"—a direct and negative impact from a decision—before being allowed to speak. No other members of the public demonstrated standing to comment on the agenda items.
Follow-ups The Board voted to continue the legislative public hearing for a text amendment to Chapter 54 Zoning of the Town of Woodfin Code of Ordinances until the July 2024 meeting. The date for this continuation was adjusted from July 2nd to July 9th at the request of the applicant. Staff will continue to process and prepare for the next meeting regarding this item.
Impact These decisions allow for specific development projects to proceed with modifications to standard zoning requirements. The approval at 66 Lake Town Lane permits the construction of a new single-family house on a steep parcel, provided the retaining wall is aesthetically blended with the landscape. The approval at 15 Elk Mountain Road allows an existing commercial property to retain its current layout while converting to office use, provided the buffer strip is restored if the non-conforming shed is removed. The continued review of the zoning text amendment indicates that changes to land use definitions and allowed uses in the Town of Woodfin Code of Ordinances are still under consideration.
Meeting Video & Transcript