Amendment to Graffiti Definition
Public Safety Committee (Virtual) (Mar 26, 2026) · March 26, 2026 at 11:00 AM
Revision to Chapter 10 of the Asheville Code of Ordinances to Amend Article VI, Regulation of Graffiti.
Documents
- Amendment to Graffiti Definition.pdfOrdinance text · PDF · 9 pages
What was said
And for this, I'm going to turn it over to Director Amy Deaton, Jess Foster, Dylan Wingler, and Janice Ashley. Good morning, Council Member Hess and Councilwoman Smith. I'm Janice Ashley and Deputy City Attorney, and I believe I'm taking the lead on presenting this. Amy Deaton, Director of Public Works, Jess Foster, and Dylan are all on the call if you have additional questions for them. But before I begin, I would like to give full credit to Assistant City Attorney Carly Gillingham, who is responsible for doing all the research into this amendment on the graffiti ordinance and preparing these slides and the information, doing research for what municipalities across North Carolina are doing in terms of their graffiti ordinances, and also in working closely with public works, staff and sanitation. and streets on this matter. So I am going to go ahead and begin my presentation. Let's start with key takeaways. So the city's code of ordinances sections 110 through 115 regulates graffiti as a public nuisance. The current definition of graffiti in section 1010 includes temporary, easily removable chalk and other water soluble materials, unless they're used in connection with traditional children's activities, or any lawful business or public purpose or activity. The proposed amendment would modify the definition of graffiti to remove chalk from the general definition, but add or define sprayable chalk to include industrial less soluble sprayable chalk similar to spray paint. It would remove undefined terms like lawful business and public purpose of activity which were deemed to be kind of ambiguous and it would exclude chalk markings from the definition of graffiti so long as they're placed on the streets or sidewalks and do not pose any public safety risk. And the ordinance would keep the exceptions for any markings done for utilities or surveys. Next slide, please. A little background to this. The graffiti ordinance was first passed in 2014. The ordinance allows both criminal and civil enforcement via penalties to perpetrators and property owners who fail to remove graffiti after notice, and that all comes from state statutes. It for appeals of enforcement actions. And again, the current definition of graffiti includes chalk, unless it is used in connection with traditional children's activities, such as drawings of bases for baseball games, hopscotch, or similar activities, or in connection with any lawful business or public purpose or activity. And again, Carly did a lot of research and our definition, including Chuck and having this exception for children's games is quite common across North Carolina. This is the way they were all written. The amendment though is intended to update the ordinance according to evolving First Amendment legal guidance to improve clarity and to ensure efficiency of staff resources. Next slide please. The impetus for this amendment came when in In November, a resident was cited for chalk markings made on a public sidewalk. And that was appealed to the, they received a notice of violation and a citation. And then they appealed that. The city has an appeals committee, which is convened of department directors per our ordinance. The appeals committee recommended upholding the notice of violation because that is precise, ordinance at the time, our current ordinance did prohibit chalk writings other than children's games. But they also recommended removing the citation and ask for consideration of amending the ordinance for clarity and efficiency. Consistent with the committee's recommendation, Interim City Manager Ben Woody issued his decision on the appeal to the resident, waiving the civil penalty but upholding the nov notice of violation and then members of count city council have now requested an amendment that would remove unnecessary restrictions on sidewalk chalk next please so the amendment is quite straightforward it really is about amending