Historic Resources Commission
April 8, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 3 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Historic Resources Commission (HRC) of the City of Asheville held an in-person meeting on April 8, 2026. The agenda focused on reviewing applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (COAs) and preliminary subdivision approvals for properties within Asheville’s historic districts, including the Biltmore Village and Montford neighborhoods. The commission also addressed preliminary local landmark designation applications and routine administrative business.
Key Decisions The commission voted to adopt the minutes and findings of fact from the March 11, 2026 meeting, with the vote passing 16-0. The application for 265 Cumberland Avenue was continued to the May meeting, with the vote passing 16-0. The commission approved several COA applications, all of which passed with no recorded votes against:
- 9 Kitchin Place: Approval for the replacement and modification of an existing storefront and the replacement of rear elevation windows (5-0).
- 16 Short Street: Approval for the installation of fifteen solar panels on the south-facing portion of the roof (5-0).
- 255 Cumberland Avenue: Approval for the replacement of garage doors and a pedestrian door on the east elevation (3-0).
- 227 Cumberland Avenue: Approval for the removal of three existing stained glass windows (4-0).
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was devoted to preliminary reviews of proposed changes at two local landmark properties: Zealandia (1 Vance Gap Road) and Walton Street Park (570 Walton Street). For Zealandia, the owners proposed replacing the slate roof, enclosing the historic pool building with new windows, removing doors to create an open breezeway, and adding an outdoor kitchen and recreational space. Commissioners expressed concerns regarding the impact of the breezeway and outdoor kitchen on the property’s historic character and its National Register listing. The commission recommended seeking advice from the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) before making a final decision.
Similarly, the commission reviewed a plan to repurpose the historic pool and building at Walton Street Park into a community space, which included an outdoor kitchen. Commissioners raised concerns about whether the breezeway and kitchen would be in keeping with the park’s historic character. Staff reported that the commission would seek technical assistance from the North Carolina Historic Preservation Office (HPO) regarding this project. The commission also discussed preliminary applications for local landmark designation for the E.W. Grove Office Building and the Feldman House, and decided to award the HRC Award to Buncombe County Special Collections and Todd Gragg for their work in preserving local history.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to gather additional information on the window materials at 9 Kitchin Place. The commission will seek advice from the SHPO regarding the proposed changes at Zealandia and technical assistance from the NC HPO regarding the Walton Street Park project. Staff will schedule site visits for the preliminary local landmark designation applications. The 265 Cumberland Avenue application will be reviewed again at the May meeting.
Impact These decisions allow property owners in historic districts to proceed with repairs, renovations, and improvements that align with preservation standards. The approvals for 9 Kitchin Place, 16 Short Street, 255 Cumberland Avenue, and 227 Cumberland Avenue permit specific alterations, such as storefront repairs, solar panel installation, and door replacements. The deferral of the Zealandia and Walton Street Park projects for further review by state preservation offices ensures that significant changes to local landmarks are evaluated for their impact on historic integrity before final approval.
Meeting Video & Transcript