Planning and Zoning Commission
May 6, 2026 at 5:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 4 h 19 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Planning and Zoning Commission of the City of Asheville convened on May 6, 2026, to address administrative updates and hold public hearings on three zoning map amendments. The primary focus of the meeting was the review of two large-scale affordable housing developments in the Shiloh neighborhood, alongside a request to rezone a commercial property. The commission also received updates on the city’s Comprehensive Plan and Development Regulations Update project and the Missing Middle Housing study.
Key Decisions The commission approved the minutes from the April 1, 2026 meeting by a vote of 5-0. Regarding the zoning requests, the commission voted to continue the request for 35 Pond St to an uncertain date at the applicant's request, passing 6-0. For the 1116 Sweeten Creek Rd project, the commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the conditional zoning request. However, the commission failed to reach a decision on the 99999 Caribou Rd project; both the motion to recommend approval and the motion to recommend denial of the conditional zoning request failed with a 3-3 vote.
Discussion Highlights The discussion on the 99999 Caribou Rd project, a 100-unit affordable housing development, centered on traffic impacts, neighborhood character, and infrastructure challenges, particularly regarding pedestrian access. Staff Coordinator Clay Mitchell reiterated the staff recommendation for approval with conditions, including a reduced parking ratio, tree preservation, and pedestrian connectivity improvements. The Chair summarized the discussion and thanked staff for their thorough work. Commissioner Faircloth emphasized the importance of providing affordable housing options while acknowledging the associated challenges, and Commissioner Bruhl highlighted the need for ongoing communication between the developer, city staff, and the community.
For the 1116 Sweeten Creek Rd project, a 126-unit affordable housing development, discussions focused on parking lot size, the need for formal economic impact analyses, and aligning decisions with the city’s “resilient economy” goal. Commissioner Anzalito made the motion to recommend approval, citing alignment with city goals. Commissioners Faircloth and Ziafsky supported including economic impact information and encouraging voluntary data submissions from applicants.
Community Input Public comments on the 1116 Sweeten Creek Rd project largely echoed concerns about the economic impact analysis and suggested exploring diverse housing styles, such as blending townhome and multifamily housing to better integrate with existing neighborhoods. One resident passionately advocated for prioritized upgrades to Sweeten Creek Road, while another expressed frustration regarding the status of road improvements.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to explore incorporating economic impact information into future reports and presentations, potentially through voluntary applicant submissions. The commission scheduled an offline discussion to explore how to integrate economic impact analysis more fully into the city’s planning process. Additionally, the city will evaluate upgrading bus stops with shelters near the 1116 Sweeten Creek Rd development. For the 99999 Caribou Rd project, the city will work with the applicant and community to improve pedestrian access, and staff will continue to monitor the project to ensure compliance with approved conditions.
Impact These decisions impact the Shiloh neighborhood by advancing or pausing significant affordable housing projects. The recommendation to approve the 1116 Sweeten Creek Rd project moves that development toward final approval by Asheville City Council. The lack of a decision on the 9999 Caribou Rd project means that request will require further review. Both projects include 100% affordable housing units leased to households earning less than 80% of the Area Median Income for a minimum of 20 years, addressing the city’s goal to increase affordable housing supply. The continuation of the 35 Pond St request delays that specific rezoning decision.
Meeting Video & Transcript