Historic Resources Commission
May 13, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 3 h 13 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
At a glance
- Approved four renovation permits, including a depot renovation and a porch enclosure.
- Adopted amendments to Montford design standards for additions 10-0.
- Delayed a decision on fencing amendments until the July meeting 6-2.
- Approved nominations for the new Executive Committee 6-2.
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: May 13, 2026
The Historic Resources Commission (HRC) of Asheville and Buncombe County held its regular meeting on May 13, 2026, at Asheville City Hall. The agenda included the presentation of the Historic Resources Champion Award, the approval of previous minutes, public hearings on several Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) applications, and discussions regarding amendments to the Montford Historic District design standards.
Key Decisions and Votes
The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the April 8, 2026 meeting. During public hearings, the HRC voted to approve Certificates of Appropriateness for four properties:
- 265 Cumberland Avenue: The commission approved the application to widen a driveway and relocate a retaining wall (9-0).
- 30 Lodge Street: The commission approved the application for the renovation of the Southern Railway Passenger Depot, including the removal of non-historic enclosures and the installation of new doors and windows (9-0).
- 174 Montford Avenue: The commission approved the application to modify the roofline on the rear elevation (14-0).
- 315 Pearson Drive: The commission approved the application to enclose a rear porch and modify windows (14-0).
Regarding the 570 Walton Street (Walton St Park) application for the adaptive reuse of a pool structure, the hearing was rescheduled to the June HRC meeting.
In other business, the commission voted to adopt amendments to pages 11 and 89 of the Montford Design Standards regarding additions (10-0). However, a motion to move the fencing amendments back to the July HRC meeting passed with a vote of 6-2. Additionally, the commission approved nominations for the Executive Committee (6-2), selecting Ms. Gorman as Chair, Ms. Moxley as Vice-Chair, Ms. Watkins as 2nd Vice-Chair, and Mr. Skouby as 3rd Vice-Chair.
Discussion Highlights
The meeting opened with the presentation of the Historic Resources Champion Award, recognizing Dr. Todd Gregg for his documentary Black in Asheville, the Come Hell or High Water Project for archiving stories following Tropical Storm Helene, and the Stumptown/Montford Fund for its work with the community land trust.
A significant portion of the meeting focused on proposed amendments to the Montford Historic District design standards, a process initiated two years prior. The most contentious aspect was the modification of fence regulations. After extensive discussion balancing resident concerns about privacy and security with the preservation of historic character, the commission voted to delay a final decision on the fencing amendments until the July meeting. Commissioners indicated that more time was needed to review historical documentation and consider community feedback gathered from a February 2026 survey.
During the review of the 30 Lodge Street project, staff noted the importance of using breathable, historically appropriate materials, such as lime-based plaster, to ensure long-term structural integrity, particularly in flood-prone areas. Commissioners also emphasized that the HRC functions as a quasi-judicial body that applies specific standards to material evidence rather than setting policy or judging the desirability of projects.
Community Input
Public comments were generally focused on the integrity of historic preservation standards. Several members of the public questioned whether proposed modern materials, such as aluminum doors or certain siding types, were appropriate for sensitive historical structures, advocating instead for wood or historically accurate finishes. Regarding the 265 Cumberland Avenue retaining wall, a key debate centered on whether the proposal constituted a necessary repair of deterioration or an unacceptable wholesale replacement that altered the structure's location.
Follow-ups
- 30 Lodge Street: The applicant is required to submit revised wood door specifications for staff review and approval.
- 315 Pearson Drive: The applicant must submit revised wood window and door specifications, as well as existing and proposed side elevations showing window opening modifications, for staff review and approval.
- Montford Design Standards: The Executive Committee will determine next steps regarding the fencing amendments, and staff will be consulted regarding scheduling a special work session.
- White Oak Tree Designation: Ms. Bowen agreed to discuss with a City Council member the possibility of designating a 400-year-old White Oak tree as historic, acting on her own behalf to explore jurisdictional options.
Impact
These decisions allow property owners to proceed with renovations that align with historic district guidelines, provided they meet the specific conditions attached to their approvals, such as using matching materials and obtaining necessary permits. The delay in the Montford fencing amendments reflects the commission’s commitment to thoroughly reviewing community input and historical context before changing regulatory standards. The upcoming HRC Education Event on June 12, 2026, at the Young Men’s Institute (YMI) will further engage the community in preservation efforts.
Meeting Video & Transcript