City Council Meeting
July 23, 2024 at 12:00 PM
- 4 h 12 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
At a glance
- Approved $80M in general obligation bonds for a November referendum 6-0.
- Approved conditional zoning for the New Haw Creek development 5-1.
- Designated the F.W. Woolworth Building a local historic landmark.
- Adopted the 2024-2025 CDBG and HOME fund action plan.
City Council Meeting Recap: July 23, 2024
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on July 23, 2024, focusing on significant financial approvals, infrastructure contracts, and land use decisions. The agenda included the acceptance of state funding for water infrastructure, the approval of $80 million in General Obligation (GO) bonds for a November referendum, and the designation of a local historic landmark. The council also addressed a conditional zoning request for a new residential development and approved numerous contracts for ongoing city projects, including renovations to McCormick Field and repairs to the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium.
Key Decisions and Votes
The council passed a series of resolutions and ordinances, most by unanimous vote (6-0). Major financial actions included:
- Lead Service Line Replacement: The council accepted $1,998,965 in funding from the N.C. Dept. of Water Infrastructure to identify and replace lead service lines.
- 2024 Water Revenue Bonds: The council approved the Bond Order and Bond Resolution for up to $30 million in Water Revenue Bonds, primarily to fund the Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) Project.
- General Obligation (GO) Bonds: The council approved the adoption of $80 million in GO Bonds, divided into four $20 million categories: Housing, Transportation, Parks & Recreation, and Public Safety. This places the bond question on the ballot for a special referendum on November 5, 2024.
- CDBG and HOME Funds: The council adopted the 2024–2025 Annual Action Plan for Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnerships Program funds, along with the associated budget amendments.
Infrastructure and facility contracts were also approved, including:
- McCormick Field: Resolutions authorizing contracts with Frank L. Blum Construction (for construction management), Terracon Consultants (for special inspections), and an amendment to the lease with DeWine Seeds - Silver Dollar Baseball LLC. The council also approved the use of Schlage hardware as a preferred alternate.
- Water Infrastructure: Contracts with WK Dickson (Shiloh Service Line Find and Replace), Kimley Horn (Coxe Avenue Water Main), CDM Smith (PLC/SCADA Process Automation), and Cavanaugh & Assoc. (Advanced Metering Infrastructure).
- Other Facilities: A contract with MB Haynes Corporation for HVAC repairs at the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium, a contract amendment with Walker Consultants for parking garage repairs, and a contract with T.P. Howard’s Plumbing Co. for ADA improvements in parking garages.
- Sustainability and Community Programs: Agreements with Asheville GreenWorks (waste reduction), Bountiful Cities (Food Policy Action Plan), and Green Built Alliance (Blue Horizons Project).
- Opioid Settlement: A resolution authorizing the City Attorney to enter into a settlement agreement with Kroger Co.
Regarding land use, the council voted 5-1 to approve the conditional zoning for the "Meadows at New Haw Creek" development at 767 New Haw Creek Rd. Councilwoman Kim Roney was the sole vote against. The project proposes 84 new housing units (49 single-family homes and 35 townhomes) on a 27.05-acre site.
The council also approved the designation of the F.W. Woolworth Company Building at 25 Haywood Street as a local historic landmark, following a unanimous recommendation from the Historic Resources Commission. Additionally, the council approved a budget ordinance amendment to adjust the effective date of the Pay & Classification Plan and adopted the Board of Alcoholic Beverage Control’s Travel Policy.
Discussion Highlights
During the public hearing on the GO Bonds, Assistant City Manager Ben Woody explained that state law prohibits city staff and elected officials from advocating for the bond and bans the use of public funds for advocacy materials. Director of Finance Tony McDowell noted that if voters approve the bonds, the debt service would require a 2.6% property tax rate increase next year, estimated at approximately $110 per year for the average residential taxpayer.
In the context of the Pay & Classification Plan amendment, Ben Woody stated, "Wages based on the cost of housing is how we're gonna recruit and retain city staff that can provide the services our community deserves."
Community Input
During the consent agenda, a representative of the Asheville Firefighters Association expressed concern that the newly released fire pay plan worsened pay "compression" (the gap between ranks) by 0.4% to 1.8%, contrary to earlier assurances. The representative stated that senior firefighters would lose tens of thousands of dollars over their careers due to the plan. In response, Ben Woody stated that the council had voted for an aggressive pay increase because it was "well-deserved and needed," and expressed hope that staff could continue working with the association to ensure the plan does not undermine their goals.
During the public hearing for the F.W. Woolworth Building landmark designation, a public commenter highlighted the building's significance as a site of 1960s civil rights sit-ins, noting that Charles R. Mosley, a founder of the Student, was arrested there. The commenter thanked the council for recognizing this history. No specific reply to the content of this comment was recorded prior to the vote.
Follow-ups
- Firefighter Pay: Ben Woody stated that staff would continue to work with the firefighters to ensure the pay plan does not undermine their goals and that the council would revisit pay for all employees, including fire, in the next budget cycle.
- Civil Rights Marker: Staff suggested pursuing a state civil rights trail marker for the Woolworth site to provide more interpretive context than a standard plaque. Staff stated they would reach out to the state to ask about parameters for such a marker and would welcome the help of the African-American Heritage Commission.
- Bond Advocacy: Ben Woody stated that staff would work with outside groups, such as the Chamber of Commerce, to request assistance for bond advocacy, as city staff are prohibited from advocating for the bond themselves.
- Right-of-Way Closure: The council set a public hearing for August 27, 2024, to consider the permanent closure of a paper right-of-way on 34 Hiawassee Street, which is intended to facilitate a land exchange with Duke Energy for a downtown substation rebuild.
Impact on Residents
The approval of the $80 million GO Bond package is a significant decision for residents, as it will determine the scope of future improvements to housing, transportation, parks, and public safety facilities. If approved by voters in November, these projects will be funded through an increase in property taxes. The acceptance of lead service line replacement funding ensures that the city can proceed with identifying and replacing lead pipes in underserved areas, improving water safety for residents. The conditional zoning approval for the Meadows at New Haw Creek development adds 84 new housing units to the area, subject to conditions including sidewalk construction, tree preservation, and a public access easement for a future greenway. Finally, the historic landmark designation of the F.W. Woolworth Building preserves a key site of Asheville’s civil rights history and makes the property eligible for a 50% annual property tax deferral.
Meeting Video & Transcript