Buncombe County Audit Committee Meeting
January 21, 2025 at 9:16 AM
- 1 h 50 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Buncombe County Audit Committee Meeting Recap: January 21, 2025
The Buncombe County Audit Committee convened on January 21, 2025, to review the county’s fiscal health, approve internal auditing standards, and address the ongoing impacts of Hurricane Helene on financial operations. The meeting focused on strengthening internal controls, updating audit protocols to align with international best practices, and reviewing the results of the fiscal year 2024 external audit.
External Audit Results and Contract Amendment The committee reviewed the fiscal year 2024 external audit conducted by Mauldin & Jenkins, which resulted in an unmodified, or "clean," opinion on the county’s financial statements. Despite the clean opinion, the audit identified three specific findings: a material weakness in internal controls related to prior period accounting adjustments for the Opioid Settlement Fund and information technology contracts; a significant deficiency in the management of allowable program costs; and a material weakness in the secondary review of program participant eligibility for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) cases. County staff stated they do not disagree with these findings and presented a corrective action plan that includes immediate implementation of enhanced review processes, staff training by January 31, 2025, and the creation of new reporting and contingency plans by late February 2025. Additionally, the committee considered a proposed contract amendment with Mauldin & Jenkins to extend the audit submission deadline to January 31, 2025, and increase the contract fee from $192,000 to $215,000. The fee increase was attributed to the need to audit eight major federal and state programs rather than the originally contracted five, while the timeline extension was due to business interruptions caused by Hurricane Helene.
Internal Audit Standards and Charter A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to aligning the Internal Audit department with the Institute of Internal Auditors' Global Internal Audit Standards, commonly known as the "Red Book." The committee discussed the differences between the Red Book, which emphasizes proactive risk assessment and consulting services, and the "Yellow Book," which is geared toward external audits. The committee agreed to adopt the Red Book standards and approved a draft audit charter based on these guidelines. The charter defines the purpose, authority, and independence of the internal audit function, establishing that the Audit Director reports functionally to the Audit Committee and administratively to the County Manager. It also mandates that the internal audit function maintain full access to all county functions and records and implement a quality assurance program that includes external assessments at least once every five years.
Impact of Hurricane Helene and Staffing Challenges The Internal Audit Director reported that Hurricane Helene significantly disrupted the department's operations, forcing staff to be reassigned to manage county distribution warehouses, which prevented the completion of a planned audit of the warehousing process due to independence considerations. The department is currently operating under a hiring freeze, which complicates efforts to fill positions, including the retirement of a long-time auditor. The committee acknowledged that the risks facing the county have changed since the last risk assessment due to the hurricane and identified a new risk assessment as a priority for the coming fiscal year. The department plans to begin filling staffing vacancies once the hiring freeze ends and to develop process documentation and a departmental strategic plan in fiscal year 2026.
Audit Plan and Reporting Procedures The committee approved an internal audit plan that includes an audit of the county’s P-Card (procurement card) system, which will review policies, procedures, and spending patterns both before and after Hurricane Helene. The plan also includes the fiscal year 2026 risk assessment. The committee discussed and established procedures for regular updates from the Internal Audit Director, including email summaries and discussions at committee meetings, as well as protocols for escalating significant findings to the full Board of Commissioners. The committee also addressed the reappointment of committee secretarial duties, a procedural item listed on the agenda.
Financial Context The meeting included a review of the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report for fiscal year 2024, which showed that the county’s total net position increased by $19.3 million, ending at $8.3 million, primarily driven by the recognition of Opioid Settlement funds. The General Fund’s available fund balance was $70.3 million, which is 1.4% higher than the county’s minimum policy requirement. The report noted that the county maintains an Aaa rating from Moody’s Investor Service and a AAA rating from Standard and Poor’s. The financial documents also highlighted that the county’s Emergency Operations Center remained active as of December 2024, transitioning from emergency response to long-term recovery, and that the next countywide property revaluation was delayed due to the hurricane’s impacts.
Next Steps The committee did not state specific next steps beyond the corrective action timelines outlined in the external audit findings and the internal audit plans for the upcoming fiscal years. The corrective actions for the external audit findings have specific deadlines, including training by January 31, 2025, and the establishment of contingency plans by February 10, 2025. The internal audit department plans to begin approved audit work and attempt to fill staffing positions once the hiring freeze ends.
Meeting Video & Transcript