Skip to main content

Board of Equalization and Review Meeting

January 14, 2025 at 1:08 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Next: Feb 24 meeting
  • 1 h 20 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Board of Equalization and Review Meeting Recap: January 14, 2025

The Buncombe County Board of Equalization and Review (BER) convened on January 14, 2025, to establish its leadership and receive training on its statutory duties. The meeting served as the inaugural session for the new board, focusing on the transition from the Board of County Commissioners to a specialized body responsible for property tax appeals. The agenda included electing officers, a meeting with the North Carolina Department of Revenue (NCDOR), and discussions regarding pending 2024 appeals and late exemption applications.

The board began by electing Mr. Brandt Barnett as Chairperson and Ms. Glenda Weiner as Vice-Chair, with both individuals accepting their nominations. The discussion clarified that the Chair presides over meetings and handles quasi-judicial hearings, requiring neutrality and a decision-making process based strictly on presented evidence. The Vice-Chair will step in if the Chair is unavailable. The board was informed that it operates under the North Carolina "Machinery Act," which establishes the process for property tax appeals and presumes that all taxpayers have an obligation to list their property for accurate assessment.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to an abbreviated training session provided by the NCDOR, necessitated by delays in completing appeals timely filed in 2024. The presentation outlined the multi-stage appeal process, which moves from informal assessor reviews to formal BER hearings, and potentially to the state Property Tax Commission or the court system. The board was educated on key legal principles, including the presumption that ad valorem tax assessments are correct, placing the burden of proof on the taxpayer to demonstrate that an assessment was arbitrary or illegal. The training also covered "discovery" appeals, which occur when taxpayers fail to list property or report changes, resulting in significant penalties for the current year and the five preceding years.

Regarding pending business, the board discussed late exemption applications. A motion was made to accept these late applications, allowing staff to proceed with reviewing them based on good cause. The board also addressed the scheduling of hearings for the remaining 2024 appeals. While the agenda called for deciding on the first hearing date and adjourn/convene dates, no formal action on specific dates was taken during this session. Instead, the board was advised that newspaper notice must be published three times, with initial publication occurring 10 days prior to the first meeting.

The board was reminded of its obligations under North Carolina’s Sunshine Laws, requiring all deliberations and decisions to be conducted in open meetings. Members were advised to maintain confidentiality regarding sensitive information, such as federal tax data, and to avoid ex parte communications or private discussions about pending appeals. The presentation highlighted the importance of impartiality, noting that board members must recuse themselves if a conflict of interest arises, such as involving relatives, corporate interests, or fee appraisals by county employees.

There were no public comments during this meeting. Regarding next steps, Eric Euler agreed to send out an email poll to determine the dates for upcoming hearings, with formal action on those dates to be taken at a future meeting. Board members were also instructed to reach out to Kurt Euler, the County Attorney, with any questions or concerns, and will receive basic rules of procedure and operating guidelines from county staff. The meeting concluded with an emphasis on the board’s role as a "really important board" providing valuable service to the community through neutral, evidence-based decision-making.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches