Planning & Zoning Commission – September 4, 2024
September 4, 2024 at 3:05 PM
- 5 h 8 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: September 4, 2024
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened on September 4, 2024, to address a range of quasi-judicial hearings, comprehensive plan policies, and development proposals. The meeting included procedural updates, discussions on housing and displacement, and reviews of specific land use requests, including a large-scale development project and amendments to tree preservation ordinances.
Key Decisions The Commission made several formal determinations during the session. It voted to approve the Special Use Permit for the New Hope New Beginning Group Home. Regarding the 107 Glendale Avenue rezoning request from RS8 to RM16, the Commission voted to recommend approval, though this recommendation is contingent on the concurrent development of anti-displacement strategies. Additionally, the Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval of proposed amendments to the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance, which aim to clarify heritage tree documentation and streamline permitting processes.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on housing policy and equity. Commissioners discussed the challenges of relying on developers to address community benefit and displacement, noting that City Council is considering a pause on residential rezoning efforts until these concerns are addressed. The discussion also touched on a $20 million affordable housing bond on the upcoming November ballot, with a presentation on previous housing bond successes planned to inform voters.
The Commission spent considerable time reviewing the Hill Street/Michael Street development project, which proposes an amendment to the Hill Street Urban Village Master Plan. The project includes 337 residential units, approximately 20,000 square feet of commercial space, and 859 parking spaces. Discussion centered on the historical significance of the area, design refinements such as vegetative screening and creek restoration, and traffic analysis. One commissioner argued that current Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) metrics for traffic analysis are flawed and fail to account for induced demand.
Other policy discussions included the potential addition of a formal land acknowledgement to the City’s Comprehensive Plan, which the Commission expressed general support for exploring. Staff are expected to provide guidance on the procedural steps for this inclusion. The Commission also discussed increased engagement with the Urban Forestry Commission and received an update from the Housing Work Group regarding potential revisions to project-level thresholds for affordable housing incentives.
Community Input Public comment was provided regarding the Hill Street/Michael Street development project. A representative from the Historic Stumptown Neighborhood Association emphasized the importance of preserving the legacy of the Stubtown/Shallow community, noting the area’s history as a Black economic center. The applicant’s advocate challenged the city’s classification of a separate property as a "group home" during the hearing for that permit.
Follow-ups Several specific actions were agreed upon by members and staff during the meeting. Staff will collaborate with the Commission to explore options for adding a land acknowledgement to the Comprehensive Plan and will research how other municipalities handle recovery homes within residential areas. The Chair agreed to reach out to the Urban Forestry Commission chair to explore options for increased communication. Staff will provide an update in October on the Housing Work Group’s revisions to project-level thresholds. Regarding the Hill Street project, staff will work with the developer to determine specifics of the trail system, and the developer agreed to provide a spreadsheet demonstrating intensity calculations, investigate the difference in parking spaces between the approved plan and the current proposal, and continue follow-up conversations with community groups.
Impact These decisions and discussions have direct implications for housing availability, neighborhood character, and environmental preservation in Asheville. The recommendation to approve the Glendale Avenue rezoning, linked to anti-displacement strategies, reflects an ongoing effort to balance development with community stability. The unanimous recommendation to approve the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance amendments signals a strengthened approach to protecting existing trees during development. The extensive review of the Hill Street project highlights the tension between high-density development and the preservation of historical and cultural community identity, with the Commission providing advisory comments to City Council, which will make the final decision on the master plan amendment.
Meeting Video & Transcript