Skip to main content

Board of Adjustment 02/26/26

February 26, 2026 at 6:00 PM

  • 1 h 15 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

The Town of Montreat Board of Adjustment held its regular meeting on February 26, 2026. The primary business of the evening involved the review and decision of two variance requests, which allow property owners to deviate from standard zoning regulations. The board also adopted the minutes from its previous regular meeting and clarified procedural rules regarding quorum and voting requirements.

The board began by adopting the meeting agenda and the minutes from the January 22, 2026, regular meeting. Both motions passed with a vote of 6-0. The board then moved to the first variance request for 435 Greybeard Trail. Applicant Powell A. Fraser, along with part-owner Mary Eloise Fraser Shepherd, sought permission to reduce the required side setback from 15 feet to 4 feet on the southern side of the property. This reduction would allow for the construction of a covered porch on an existing stone patio. The board voted to grant the variance, a decision that passed 6-0. The board subsequently approved the written order for this variance, which also passed 6-0.

The second item on the agenda was a variance request for 329 North Carolina Terrace, associated with the William Black Lodge. Applicants Lindsey Richards and Thomas A. Brown requested a reduction of the building setback from 25 feet to 4.9 feet to add a deck to an existing rental cottage. The board voted to approve this variance, with the motion passing 6-0. Following a brief recess, the board approved the written order for this variance, which also passed 6-0.

During the hearing for 435 Greybeard Trail, testimony was provided by the applicants and a neighbor. Mary Eloise Fraser Shepherd explained that the covered porch would provide space for family gatherings and help manage water drainage and erosion around a hemlock tree. Jeremy Sexton of Sexton Deck Builders confirmed the structure would be a screened porch with a one-sided shed roof. A public commenter, a neighbor at 433 Greybeard Trail, provided historical context, noting that the 4-foot setback request stems from a 1964 renovation where improvements extended beyond property lines, requiring a neighbor to deed over approximately 4 feet to resolve encroachment issues. He expressed strong support for the application.

For the 329 North Carolina Terrace request, Reverend Thomas Brown, director of the William Black Lodge, testified regarding the property’s history and the lodge’s mission. He noted that the lodge was established in 1917, with the current building opening in 1950, and that the rental cottage was built in the 1950s. Brown explained that a partnership with the Northeast Georgia Presbytery involves $150,000 in funding for renovation, which includes providing 13 weeks of free lodging annually for ministry workers. He stated that the deck would provide mountain views and outdoor access for guests. Board member David Neel shared his experience staying at the cottage, noting it is a "tight space" that would benefit from the addition of the deck.

In new business, Town Attorney Brandon Freeman clarified the voting rules for the seven-member board. For simple majority votes, such as special use permits, a quorum of four members is required, and approval requires a majority of votes cast. For variance decisions, which require a supermajority, 80% of the total board must vote in favor. For a seven-member board, this equals six members; if only five members are present, a variance cannot be heard. The board emphasized that these hearings are quasi-judicial, meaning decisions must be based on facts and regulations rather than personal opinions.

The meeting adjourned at 6:15 p.m. Interim Zoning Administrator Alexis Baker indicated that two additional applications are pending but are awaiting additional information. She recommended that the board hold its next meeting on March 26, 2026, if needed to address those applications.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches