Board of Adjustment 2/22/24
February 22, 2024 at 6:00 PM
- 1 h 34 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Town of Montreat Board of Adjustment held a meeting on February 22, 2024, to conduct routine business and hold an evidentiary hearing regarding a variance request for property at 325 North Carolina Terrace. The primary focus of the session was a continued hearing for a request to increase the approved graded area and development intensity ratio on a steeply sloped lot subject to the Hillside Development Ordinance.
Key Decisions The Board took four recorded votes during the meeting. First, the Board approved the agenda as presented by a vote of 4-0. Second, the Board voted 5-0 to enter the new plan and documents into evidence. Third, the Board voted 4-1 to approve the variance request (VA-2023-03) as presented, with Ed Kramer voting against the motion. Finally, the Board adopted the minutes from the January 25, 2024, meeting by a vote of 5-0. Additionally, the Board swore in Ed Kramer as a new Regular Member. The applicant withdrew the separate request for a Special Use Permit (SUP-2023-02) for a detached garage, as the garage was removed from the revised plans associated with the approved variance.
Discussion Highlights The central discussion revolved around the variance request submitted by a public commenter on behalf of Dow Montreat, LLC. The request sought to increase the approved graded area from 40% to 85.2% and the development intensity ratio from 0.30 to 0.472. A public commenter testified that the primary purpose of the changes was to improve accessibility and manage stormwater, noting that the family had incorporated feedback from the Board and neighbors into the revised plan submitted on February 8, 2024. The revised plan removed the proposed garage, adjusted parking, and added new stormwater management features, including drains, storage tanks, and a detention basin.
Kayla DeChristina, the Town Zoning Administrator, presented staff findings indicating that the proposed stormwater management system sufficiently details post-development runoff control, though the applicant is required to obtain a Stormwater Control Permit prior to permit issuance. During deliberations, Ed Kramer voted against the request, arguing that the property did not meet the "unnecessary hardship" standard, which he defined as medical necessity rather than future retirement needs. He also noted that the property showed signs of poor maintenance, including clogged gutters and disconnected pipes. Other board members noted that the applicant had revised the request to meet the "minimum variance" standard as requested in the previous meeting.
Community Input A member of the public, identified in the record as a non-adjacent property owner, expressed concern about the brightness of the proposed concrete driveway. In response, staff advised that they would work with the applicant on Light Reflectance Value (LRV) standards if the request was approved. Additionally, a neighbor submitted a notarized letter expressing concerns about the project, which was entered into evidence.
Follow-ups Staff explicitly agreed to work with the applicant on Light Reflectance Value (LRV) standards regarding the driveway material. The applicant committed to implementing the stormwater management measures outlined in the revised plans, including new drains, storage tanks, and redirection of runoff, and will be responsible for monitoring these improvements to ensure they function as intended.
Impact This decision allows Dow Montreat, LLC to proceed with increased grading and development intensity on the property at 325 North Carolina Terrace. The approval is significant because it modifies the limits set by the Hillside Development Ordinance for a property with a 44.8% slope. The decision follows a review of revised plans that address stormwater management and accessibility, balancing the applicant's needs with concerns raised regarding the impact on neighboring properties and the precedent set for future variance requests in the town.
Meeting Video & Transcript