Special Called Buncombe County Schools Board of Education Meeting - May 28, 2024

Buncombe County Schools Board Addresses Vacancy, Postpones Decision

On May 28, 2024, the Buncombe County Schools Board of Education held a special called meeting focused solely on filling a vacancy created by the recent resignation of at-large representative Amanda Simpkins. The meeting, attended by all Board members, centered on a robust pool of candidates and ultimately resulted in a postponement of the final decision.

The meeting began with an overview of the application process, detailed by Superintendent Dr. Jackson. A significant number of individuals – 25 with timely applications and two late submissions – expressed interest in the position, demonstrating a strong community desire to contribute to the school system. Board members engaged in extensive discussion regarding these applications, emphasizing the importance of selecting a candidate deeply committed to public education, knowledgeable in educational policy and law, and respected within the community. Several members highlighted the depth of talent among the applicants, acknowledging the challenge in selecting a single individual.

A key point of debate arose regarding the timeline for making a decision. Board members Kim Plemons and Rob Elliott voiced concerns about the limited time available to thoroughly evaluate all candidates, suggesting individual outreach and further review would be beneficial. The Board Attorney clarified the legal implications of a tie vote, explaining that in such an event, the senior resident superior court judge of Buncombe County would ultimately appoint a replacement. Following a nomination of Pat Bryant by Board member Peggy Buchanan, the initial motion to nominate him failed with a 3-3 vote. Recognizing the need for more deliberation, a motion was unanimously approved to postpone the decision and add the matter as an action item on the Board’s regular meeting agenda for June 6th.

While no direct public comments were formally taken during the meeting, several Board members acknowledged receiving numerous calls and recommendations from community members regarding potential candidates. This underscores the high level of interest and engagement within the community surrounding this important appointment.

Looking ahead, residents can expect further discussion and a final decision on the at-large seat vacancy during the Board’s regular meeting on June 6th. In the interim, Board members indicated they will continue reviewing applications and reaching out to candidates individually. This postponement reflects the Board’s commitment to a thoughtful and informed selection process, ensuring that the chosen individual is well-prepared to represent the interests of all students and families within Buncombe County Schools. The Board's adherence to Board Policy 2115 (Unexpired Term Fulfillment) will continue to guide their deliberations.