Staff’s recommendation is (1) Provide 4.11% increase to all employees, meeting Just Economic Pledged Annual Living Wage Rate; (2) Requires an additional $4.3 million; (3) Affordable within existing resources only with fund balance usage - Any compensation increase will require use of fund balance; and (4) Staff recommendation is similar to what other municipalities in Buncombe County are considering.
City Council Meeting (Apr 9, 2024) · April 9, 2024 at 12:00 PM
What was said
And so that's what we're going to really focus on over the next few slides. So at the last meeting, actually I think we first showed this example at your retreat, you know one of the things that we really focus on as we're thinking about salary adjustments is how do they impact compression within the organization. And so we showed you all this example. This is a crew in public works that consists of four employees, a crew supervisor, a lead equipment operator, an equipment operator, and a laborer. And so we wanted to show you all the base, what the base rate is for each of those positions in our pay plan and kind of what the differential is currently between those positions. So for example, the crew supervisor, the base rate for that position is $53,414. The lead EEO2 is $48,448. And so the difference between those two positions currently salary-wise for their base rate is around 10%. Same thing, same differential between the lead EO2 and the EO2, and it's a 15 to 16 percent differential between the last two. So we showed you all this example before, and you're going to see this as we go through the slides, because we want to show you, with each of the scenarios that we ran, what the impact will be on the differential between the positions, and i.e., what kind of additional compression these recommendations might create. So the first scenario we ran for you all was consideration of a flat pay increase for all employees that would bring everyone in the organization up to the full Just Economics annual living wage. And so currently our lowest annual pay full time is $37,950. The Just Economics full living wage is $45,918. So to make those adjustments, it would require that each employee get a $7,958 increase to their pay. So we looked at that scenario. The cost to that would be about $12.5 million is our estimate for that. And then below you can see how that would impact compression. So if you look at that first column, that's the existing percent differentials that I just showed you all for those positions. If we were to implement this flat amount approach, it would shrink the differentials between each of those positions and therefore negatively impact compression to a small degree. So what are the pros and cons of that? So again, total cost would be about $12.5 million. The pros are that this would allow us to achieve the full annual living wage for all of our employees. The cons are, unfortunately, at that cost, it is unaffordable within our available resources. We also took a look at how other local governments in North Carolina are applying their compensation adjustments, and we're really not seeing any that are utilizing this flat dollar approach. They're all utilizing percent increases either as a COLA or a merit, and so this really is this this approach is really not kind of a standard practice for other local governments here in North Carolina. And then, as you saw in the previous slide, one of the cons would be that there would be a slight increase in compression between those positions if we implemented this approach. So the second scenario we looked at was a flat amount once again, it's kind of the same approach, but this time instead of applying an amount that would bring all employees up to the full living wage, we looked at how much it would cost to bring all employees up to the pledged living wage, which is $39,520. That would mean a $1,560 flat payment to all employees. The cost of that would be about two and a half million dollars and again you can see down below the impact that would have on this particular crew that we were looking at and just like with the previous scenario you would see a slight increase in compression between each of those positions if we utilize this approach and so to summarize the pros and cons of this approach again the pro is it would allow us to achieve the pledged annual living wage for all employees at two and a half million we do believe that this is affordable within our available resources for next year's budget. The cons are, again, it doesn't achieve the full annual living wage. There's that slight increase in compression that we saw before. And with this one, we do believe there would be a negative impact on morale, especially recruitment and retention for higher paid employees. And so I'll just give you an example. So if we utilize this approach, employees at the lowest end of the pay range,