Skip to main content

Planning & Zoning Commission – July 11, 2024

July 11, 2024 at 5:03 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jun 6 meetingNext: Aug 7 meeting
  • 4 h 54 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a meeting on July 11, 2024, to address administrative matters, review specific development proposals, and discuss significant updates to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). The session began with a unanimous vote to add a formal land acknowledgement recognizing the historical connection of Cherokee people to the land to the Commission’s website. The Commission also unanimously approved the minutes from the June 6, 2024 meeting.

Key Decisions

The Commission made three primary decisions during the meeting. First, regarding the Riverside Drive Development (RAD River Project) at 179 & 144 Riverside Dr., the body voted unanimously to recommend approval to City Council. This recommendation included conditions requiring the applicant to explore a signalized crosswalk or speed table for pedestrian safety, create a dedicated food truck space on the north side of the building, and improve pedestrian connectivity between the sidewalk and the greenway. Second, the Commission approved a request to rezone approximately five acres at 9999 Shoals Rd. from RS-2 (Residential Single Family Low Density) to HB (Highway Business) by a vote of 4 to 1. Third, the Commission continued Item four from the published agenda to September 4th. A vote on the Duke Energy Communication Tower proposal was pending at the time of the summary, with discussion continuing following public comment.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to proposed updates to Chapter 7 of the UDO, focusing on landscaping regulations, tree health, and housing support. Staff and presenters discussed simplifying buffer requirements to improve plant survival rates, potentially reducing parking lot tree canopy coverage from 40% to 20%, and introducing soil volume standards. Sharon Sumrall of the Urban Forestry Commission delivered a presentation emphasizing the importance of tree canopy protection. Other UDO discussions included a proposal for a green roof standard for new construction over 5,000 square feet in the Central Business District, reducing front setbacks in business districts to encourage housing, and allowing duplexes in RS2, RS4, and RS8 zoning districts as a step toward broader middle housing implementation. The Commission also debated anti-displacement strategies and the potential use of overlays, acknowledging that zoning decisions can be rooted in classism and racism.

Regarding the development proposals, the discussion on the Riverside Drive project covered height variances, affordability commitments (noting a 5% commitment versus a potential 20%), the removal of retail space, and green infrastructure. For the Long Shoals Road rezoning, the debate centered on compatibility with surrounding development, consistency with the Comprehensive Plan, and environmental concerns regarding wetlands and the Lake Julian watershed. The Duke Energy Communication Tower proposal, a 195-foot tower plus a five-foot lightning rod at 555 Brevard Road, was reviewed for technical modifications.

Community Input

Public comment was limited but recorded during the Long Shoals Road rezoning discussion. Commenters raised concerns regarding environmental impacts, specifically related to wetlands. During the Riverside Drive discussion, public input focused on the loss of mixed-use elements and pedestrian safety, including the need for a crosswalk. General public comments also noted ambiguity surrounding the proposed UDO amendments.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to several specific follow-up actions regarding the UDO updates. Staff will investigate whether soil volume calculations apply to one- and two-family dwellings, review the wording regarding the 1,500 square foot trigger for amendments to present a revised version at the next meeting, and explore how buffer trees could be counted toward canopy requirements. Additionally, staff will consult with the Riverfront Commission and Design Review Committee regarding green roofs, investigate the feasibility of using fee-in-lieu funds for tree canopy preservation, and examine the impact of a green roof mandate on Central Business District development. Staff member Mr. Bichell agreed to address identified incongruencies in the Tree Conservation Plan. For the Long Shoals Road rezoning, coordination with the Corps of Engineers regarding wetland impacts is required following approval. The applicant for the Riverside Drive development will address technical modifications, explore crosswalk options, and consider adding commercial space at the north and south ends of the building.

Impact

These decisions and discussions impact residents by shaping the physical development of the city and the rules governing land use. The approval of the Long Shoals Road rezoning allows for highway business use on a previously low-density residential parcel, while the recommendation for the Riverside Drive project moves a mixed-use development forward with specific pedestrian safety and connectivity conditions. The extensive review of UDO landscaping and housing standards aims to balance the need for new housing and walkability with the preservation of neighborhood quality and tree health. The Commission’s focus on anti-displacement strategies and equitable development reflects an effort to address historical inequities in zoning practices, which will influence future policy directions for the city.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches