Planning & Zoning Commission, Special Meeting – March 20, 2024
March 20, 2024 at 4:56 PM
- 4 h 13 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Special Meeting Recap: March 20, 2024
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a special meeting on March 20, 2024, to review a proposed rezoning and development project at 767 New Hawk Creek Road. The applicant, representing the estate of Margaret King and Warren Sugg, requested a change from the current Residential Single Family Medium Density (RS4) zoning to a Residential Expansion Conditional Zone (RES EXP-CZ). This change would allow for the construction of approximately 95 residential units on the 27.05-acre parcel, including townhomes, walking paths, and increased property line buffers. The proposal aims to align with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan by providing connectivity to the Hog Creek Greenway and future sidewalks along Hawk Creek Road.
The Commission voted 4-3 to approve the conditional zoning request for the property. The approval includes specific conditions designed to mitigate potential negative impacts, reflecting a balance between development goals and community concerns. Key conditions and next steps identified during the meeting include the requirement for the developer to obtain Department of Transportation (DOT) approval for a proposed signalized crosswalk across Newhall Creek Road. Additionally, if a "heritage tree" conservation condition is adopted, a tree survey will be required.
Discussion during the meeting focused heavily on environmental impacts, particularly the potential removal of approximately 80% of the existing mature tree canopy. Residents and commissioners expressed strong concerns about the ecological, social, and economic consequences, including the loss of wildlife habitat, increased flooding risk, and diminished climate resiliency. The debate explored options for heritage tree conservation and the feasibility of preserving larger buffer zones. Commissioners also debated the appropriateness of the proposed density of 3-5 units per acre relative to the Comprehensive Plan and existing neighborhood character, raising concerns about school enrollment, traffic congestion, and stormwater runoff.
Public comment was extensive, with a wide range of perspectives expressed regarding the project. Residents raised serious concerns about fire safety due to the valley’s topography and limited evacuation routes, prompting discussions about engaging wildfire planning experts. Other public concerns included the impact of retaining walls on buffer zones, requests for increased buffer areas, and restrictions on tree removal. The discussion also referenced neighborhood plans available on the city website, which emphasize community-driven visions for development that prioritize walkability, bikeability, safer access to parks and greenways, open space preservation, and improved stormwater management.
Regarding affordability and community engagement, commissioners discussed the need to incorporate affordability measures. While the developer committed to ongoing engagement with the community, city council, and the Technical Review Committee (TRC) to refine aspects of the project, a formal affordability plan was not immediately presented. The developer also committed to exploring potential financial mechanisms, such as land conservation trusts, to offset the economic impact of any further concessions.
Staff and member follow-ups were outlined at the conclusion of the discussion. The city attorney will work on drafting language for conditions related to the first-time homebuyer education program and affordability initiatives. Furthermore, the developer is expected to provide a detailed report on the project. The Commission’s decision to approve the conditional zoning request, despite the close vote and significant public concern, underscores the complex interplay between developer interests, community desires, and the city’s planning goals.
Meeting Video & Transcript