Design Review Committee
May 21, 2026 at 12:30 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 48 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Design Review Committee held its regular meeting on May 21, 2026, focusing on leadership elections, minute approvals, and a formal design review. The committee unanimously elected Bryan Moffitt as Chair and Michael McDonough as Vice Chair, with both votes passing 6-0. Additionally, the committee approved the minutes from the March 19, 2026 meeting by a vote of 6-0.
The primary substantive decision of the meeting concerned the exterior rehabilitation of the building at 26 Battery Park Avenue. The committee approved the project with conditions by a vote of 5-1. The approval included two specific requirements: the applicant must submit their application and evidence to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) to obtain an opinion on whether the alteration is congruous with the building’s historical significance, and the applicant must maintain the existing plane of the panel between the second and third-story windows.
Discussion Highlights
The meeting began with Chair Bryan Moffitt explaining that the committee operates as a mandatory review with voluntary compliance, noting that hotels seeking to bypass council review must receive a positive recommendation from the committee. Following the roll call, the committee addressed the vacancy in the Chair position. Moffitt stated he was willing to serve as Chair, and after nominations were called, Jeremy Goldstein moved and Joe Balcken seconded his election. For the Vice Chair position, Michael McDonough stated he would serve because he is present most of the time; Jeremy Goldstein nominated him, and Joe Balcken seconded the motion.
The central discussion involved the proposed exterior rehabilitation at 26 Battery Park Avenue, a 1926 building that is a contributing structure to the Downtown Asheville National Register Historic District. Will Pomquist, Planning and Urban Design Staff, presented the request, noting that staff deferred a recommendation due to inconsistencies with design guidelines and the potential loss of the building's contributing status. Ian Jones, representing the property owner, explained that 60 to 65 percent of the existing marble facade is damaged, cracked, and crumbling due to exposure to the elements. Jones cited a 1970 historic preservation certification stating the building was originally limestone and that the marble was added in the 1970s. He stated the goal is to return the building to its original historic significance by replacing the failing marble with limestone.
During the debate, Vice Chair Michael McDonough expressed concern about the loss of architectural detail and the potential impact on future financial tools, such as tax credits, if the building loses its contributing status. He voted against the approval. Joe Balcken suggested contacting the SHPO for an opinion to help maintain historic status. A committee member proposed the motion to approve with the condition of consulting the SHPO, which was accepted along with a friendly amendment to maintain the plane of the panel between the upper windows.
Follow-ups
Staff member Will Pomquist placed the preservation application files in the project folder linked from the agenda. The applicant, Ian Jones, agreed to email the historic preservation certification application document to staff. Furthermore, the applicant agreed to submit their application and evidence to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) to obtain an opinion on the alteration and to maintain the existing plane of the panel between the second and third-story windows.
Impact
This decision allows for the repair of a deteriorating facade on a historic building in downtown Asheville. The project aims to replace failing marble with limestone to match the building's original 1926 design. The conditions attached to the approval require the owner to seek guidance from the State Historic Preservation Office to ensure the changes align with the building's historical significance, addressing concerns raised by committee members regarding the preservation of the structure's status and architectural detail.
Meeting Video & Transcript