Skip to main content
  • 4 h 4 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On May 13, 2024, the Town Council of Black Mountain held a regular meeting to address several key municipal issues, including a public hearing on the establishment of a social district, conditional zoning requests for Montreat College, and the renovation of Cragmont Park. The session also included the approval of the consent agenda, the review of the Black Mountain Beautification Committee’s annual report, and a decision regarding the dedication of two private roads.

Key Decisions and Votes

The Council approved the consent agenda unanimously, which included minutes from previous meetings, a property tax collector report, budget amendments, and the Riverwalk Greenway Capital Project amended ordinance. However, due to concerns regarding cost monitoring and the lack of a detailed line-item breakdown, the Council tabled the Riverwalk Greenway item for further review, with a motion approved to revisit it in July.

Regarding the Cragmont Park renovation, the Council unanimously approved a resolution selecting Harper General Contractors, Inc. for design and build services, with a contract amount not to exceed $492,000. Harper scored 88 in the evaluation process, while Bloom Construction scored 80.

For Montreat College, the Council unanimously approved the conditional zoning ordinance and the corresponding zoning map amendment. This approval included an amendment that reduced the maximum height for resident halls from 75 feet to 65 feet. Additionally, the Council unanimously voted to reject the request to dedicate Francis Lane and Fay Jones Lane to the town, meaning these roads will remain private.

In the Lakeview Senior Center parking matter, no formal vote was taken, but the Council agreed in principle to a seasonal trial program. This plan reserves 12 designated parking spots (reduced from the 22 requested) for seniors with mobility issues from Memorial Day through Labor Day, Monday–Friday, 10:00 AM to 1:00 PM.

Discussion Highlights

The primary focus of the meeting was the public hearing on a Social District. Staff presented the legal framework under North Carolina law, noting municipal flexibility in defining boundaries, hours, and container requirements. The Council did not vote to adopt the social district ordinance as originally proposed (7 days a week, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.). Instead, the Council agreed to a pilot program with specific parameters: hours limited to Thursday through Sunday, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.; a duration through the end of the year with a review scheduled for the October meeting; and boundaries adjusted to stop at North Arnie Street on the west and extend to South Ridgeway on the east. The Sourwood Festival and Holly Jolly weekends are excluded from the district pending further input. The Council expressed a strong preference for prohibiting single-use plastic cups in favor of metal or reusable cups. A motion passed to continue the public hearing to a special call meeting on Wednesday, May 22, 2024, at 8:30 a.m. to finalize the ordinance language.

During the Montreat College discussion, Council members debated the height and buffer issues. Staff clarified that third-party approval for buffers on private property is legally problematic, but the college could choose from listed screening options. One member noted the 75-foot limit was for design flexibility, while another advocated for a lower limit as a compromise, leading to the final 65-foot limit.

Community Input

Public comments on the Social District were mixed. Supporters cited economic benefits, tourism, and community vibrancy, while opponents raised concerns about public safety, litter, parking, and impacts on non-alcohol businesses and residents. The Chief of Police, via memo, expressed concern about pedestrian safety on Broadway and US 70, increased workload, and noise, recommending limiting the district to special events for a one-year trial. Council Member Doug Hay agreed with the Chief’s concerns, suggesting special permits only and limited hours/days. Mayor Michael Sobol stated he was personally supportive but emphasized the town’s history of moving slowly, suggesting a limited scope start. Council Member Pam King cited Swannanoa’s successful use of $10 metal cups to discourage excessive consumption and supported prohibiting single-use plastics. Council Member Alice Berry expressed concern about the expansive map, particularly near the funeral home and a high-injury intersection, supporting a smaller area. Melinda Hester of the Chamber of Commerce stated that including the Sourwood Festival and Holly Jolly would change the flavor of these family-oriented events and requested time to gather board input.

Regarding Montreat College, a public commenter who is a former Foreign Service officer emphasized economic and cultural benefits, while a commissioner from the Town of Montreat described the college as vital to the community. A professional engineer opposed the 75-foot height limit, noting town code limits for light industrial buildings and previous master plan depictions of three-story dorms. A resident of Terry State Drive requested restrictions on college traffic, no new structures within 250 yards of homes, and physical separation from the neighborhood.

Follow-ups

Staff will draft the Social District ordinance incorporating the pilot parameters, including the specific boundaries, festival exclusions, and non-plastic cup provisions. Staff will also reach out to other municipalities regarding exceptions for long-standing festivals. Melinda Hester of the Chamber of Commerce will gather input from the Chamber board and Sourwood planning committee regarding event inclusion. The Council will hold a special call meeting on Wednesday, May 22, 2024, at 8:30 a.m. to finalize and vote on the Social District ordinance.

For Montreat College, staff and the college agreed to adjust the height limit in the conditions from 75 feet to 65 feet. Staff confirmed that paving work for the pathway near the Lakeview Senior Center to improve ADA access is included in current quotes and will start in the next few weeks. Regarding the rejected street dedication, staff noted that the roads will remain private, and residents and the fire department would need to arrange their own snow removal and access. For the Lakeview Senior Center, staff will work with the police department to clarify signage requirements and enforcement protocols for the new seasonal parking spots and will coordinate with the swim team regarding potential conflicts during events.

Impact

These decisions impact residents in several ways. The Social District pilot program will alter regulations for alcohol consumption in the downtown area for the remainder of the year, with a focus on reducing single-use plastics and limiting hours to weekends. The approval of the Montreat College expansion allows for new construction with a reduced height limit of 65 feet for resident halls, addressing some community concerns about scale while permitting growth. The rejection of the street dedication for Francis Lane and Fay Jones Lane means that maintenance and access responsibilities for these roads remain with the private owners rather than the town. Finally, the Cragmont Park renovation contract with Harper General Contractors initiates the physical improvements to the park, and the Lakeview Senior Center parking trial will provide limited, time-specific parking access for seniors with mobility issues during the summer months.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches