Skip to main content

Special Meeting: Historic Resources Commission

April 28, 2026 at 9:00 AMOnline

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Apr 27 meetingNext: May 5 meeting
  • 1 h 25 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

At a glance

  • Reviewed Executive Committee feedback on proposed changes to the Montford Historic District design standards.
  • Debated the use of case-by-case review for front yard fences, with members raising concerns about fairness and safety.
  • Agreed to remove specific case-by-case language from the draft amendments to avoid confusion.
  • Set the May 13 regular meeting as the next step to finalize recommendations and accept public comment.

Historic Resources Commission Work Session Recap: Montford Design Standard Amendments

On April 28, 2026, the Historic Resources Commission (HRC) of Asheville and Buncombe County held a virtual special work session to discuss proposed amendments to the Montford Historic District Design Standards. The meeting was strictly a discussion session; no formal votes were taken, and no public comment was accepted. The primary focus was reviewing feedback from the HRC Executive Committee on changes proposed by Montford residents in early 2024, which have been under analysis for the past two years.

The staff liaison presented a timeline indicating that the Executive Committee analyzed the proposed amendments from June to August 2024, comparing them to standards in peer North Carolina cities. After a work session was cancelled in September 2024 due to Tropical Storm Helene, the committee resumed its work in the fall of 2025. In February 2026, the city published an online survey aimed primarily at Montford residents, which ran through March 27, 2026. The Executive Committee met twice in April 2026 to refine its recommendations based on this data before presenting them to the full commission.

The Executive Committee’s analysis focused on three specific areas of the design standards: the "Purpose and Applicability" section (Page 11), front yard fences (Pages 36-37), and additions (Page 88). For Page 11, the committee recommended adding clarifying language to root the standards in the narrative description of historic character from the district’s National Register nomination. Regarding front yard fences, the committee recommended eliminating confusing language and continuing to review requests on a case-by-case basis, noting that the historic landscape character has not significantly changed and that the commission has only approved a handful of such fences in the past decade. For additions, the committee presented a refined draft that allows for additions on side elevations provided they do not impact historical features and are sufficiently setback.

Commission members engaged in a detailed debate regarding the "case-by-case" language proposed for front yard fences. Robert Mays expressed disappointment with the process, citing a lack of time for review and arguing that the current proposal makes it harder to obtain front yard fences, which he described as a "life safety issue." He noted that 76% of survey respondents wanted more front fences and suggested appointing a subcommittee or holding a work session with more notice. Bill Roberts stated he felt "blindsided" by the amendment and raised concerns that "case-by-case" review could create fair housing issues due to subjectivity. In response, Celesta Gorman stated that the case-by-case language allows flexibility for safety issues while protecting the district's character, citing the National Register designation’s emphasis on open landscapes. Jenny Bowen suggested pausing to allow commissioners more time to review the materials and figure out better wording, while Leslie Humphrey suggested that if approvals remain case-by-case, the commission should use a clear, published rubric.

During the discussion, a staff member clarified that the commission must look at the big picture and make changes that are correct with limited time, noting that resources are spread across all historic districts. The staff member agreed to remove the specific language regarding "case by case" review and the mention of side and rear yard fences from the proposed amendments to avoid confusion. Jannice Ashley, the Deputy City Attorney, noted that while real estate decisions are often made on a case-by-case basis, the legal language can be broad; she suggested defining specific circumstances or criteria to provide clarity and ensure uniform application.

No formal decisions or votes were taken at this work session. The commission agreed that the next step is to bring the amendments to the full commission at the regular meeting on May 13, 2026, where public comment will be accepted. Staff agreed to schedule a follow-up Executive Committee meeting prior to the May 13 meeting to finalize recommendations and to split the vote on the fence amendments from the other amendments to avoid holding up the process. Staff also agreed to send an email update to the neighborhood, including representatives from the Montford Neighborhood Association, and to update the project page with timeline information.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches