Historic Resources Commission
July 8, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 4 h 39 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: July 8, 2026
The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on July 8, 2026, to review preservation matters, including design standards, accessibility improvements, and new construction within the city’s historic districts. The meeting addressed routine governance items, public hearings for Certificates of Appropriateness (COA), and a significant debate regarding fence regulations in the Montford Historic District.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Commission approved the minutes and Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law from the May 13, 2026, and June 10, 2026, meetings, with both motions passing by a vote of 9-0.
The Commission voted on three Certificate of Appropriateness applications:
- Cathedral of All Souls (3 Angle Street, Biltmore Village): The Commission approved the COA with conditions by a vote of 6-3. Conditions require the submission of vestibule modifications for later review, as well as staff approval of manufacturer specifications for doors, brick samples, and paint colors. All limestone removed from the front porch must be retained, preserved, and stored on-site.
- Riverside Cemetery (53 Birch Street, Montford): The Commission approved the COA for a new burial area by a vote of 8-0. Conditions include establishing ground cover within 15 days of construction completion and installing the remainder of the landscaping within three years.
- New Construction (215 Cumberland Avenue, Montford): The Commission approved the COA for a new two-and-a-half-story residence by a vote of 7-1. Conditions require the submission of detailed specifications for porch railings, windows, and mechanical units, as well as revised garage door specifications and rear elevation drawings for staff review.
Additionally, the Commission voted 5-4 to approve proposed amendments to the Montford Design Standards regarding fence regulations.
Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the proposed amendments to the Montford Design Standards concerning fences. This item sparked considerable debate, with residents expressing concerns about the current wording, which "strongly discourages" front yard fences, and its impact on safety and aging-in-place needs. Commissioner Jane Mathews raised concerns regarding the process for introducing amendments, specifically questioning the exclusivity of the Executive Committee’s role in this matter.
The review of the Cathedral of All Souls rehabilitation project, driven by flood damage from Hurricane Helene, focused on balancing accessibility with historic character. Discussions centered on the aesthetic impact of a proposed flood wall, the historical significance of the existing vestibule, and the necessity of ADA-compliant ramps. The Commission explored alternatives to the flood wall, such as vegetation screening, and noted that the proposed vestibule design was "not preferred" because it bisects the porch and detracts from the original open design intent.
For the new construction at 215 Cumberland Avenue, Commissioners reviewed detailed plans for a 6,968-square-foot structure. Concerns were raised regarding the size of the house relative to surrounding properties, the visibility of the garage, and potential impacts on neighborhood character. Staff also noted concerns regarding the potential disturbance of unmarked graves within the property, requiring an archaeological protocol if resources are discovered during construction.
Community Input
Public comment was extensive during the discussion of the Montford fence standard amendments. Residents voiced varied perspectives, primarily focusing on safety concerns and the need for aging-in-place accommodations, which informed the Commission's subsequent vote to approve the amendments.
Follow-ups
- Staff Review: Staff will review the submitted window and mechanical unit specifications, revised garage door specifications, and rear elevation drawings related to the 215 Cumberland Avenue COA.
- Grant Support: Celeste Gorman will draft a letter of support for the Biltmore Village infrastructure project’s Tourism Development Authority (TDA) grant application, which currently has $2.5 million in funding from the North Carolina Department of Commerce. The letter will then be reviewed and signed by the Commission.
- Education and Training: Staff will distribute information regarding registration for an education event rescheduled for August 14, 2026, at the YMI, and forward registration information for a Certified Local Government (CLG) training scheduled for August 7, 2026, in Waynesville.
- Site Tours: Staff will schedule a follow-up tour of the Basilica for Commission members.
Impact on Residents
These decisions directly affect the appearance and usability of properties in the Biltmore Village and Montford Historic Districts. The approval of the Cathedral of All Souls project will allow for critical flood mitigation and accessibility upgrades, including a new ramp and restrooms, while preserving historic materials. The approval of the Riverside Cemetery expansion will create a new burial area with accessible pathways and native landscaping. The new construction on Cumberland Avenue will add a substantial new residence to the neighborhood, subject to specific design conditions to ensure compatibility with the historic district. Finally, the amendment to the Montford fence standards will change how residents in that district can utilize their front yards, reflecting a balance between historic character and modern safety needs.
Meeting Video & Transcript