Skip to main content

Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee

July 21, 2026 at 1:00 PMOnline

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jun 16 meetingNext: Aug 18 meeting
  • 1 h 38 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

At a glance

  • Recommended the nuisance vehicle ordinance amendment 3-0, redefining litter and adding vehicle definitions.
  • Sent the transit operations analysis to Council 3-0, recommending a long-term funding strategy.
  • Approved the June 16 minutes 3-0.

Key Decisions

The Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee held a virtual meeting on July 21, 2026, during which it took three formal votes. The committee first approved the action minutes from its June 16, 2026 meeting, with the motion passing 3-0. The committee then voted to recommend to City Council the repeal of Section 15-1 of Chapter 15 of the city’s solid waste management ordinance and its replacement with a revised section. This amendment redefines the term “Litter” and adds specific definitions for “Motor vehicle or vehicle” and “Nuisance motor vehicle.” This motion also passed 3-0. Finally, the committee passed a motion 3-0 for staff to bring the Asheville Rides Transit (ART) Comprehensive Operations Analysis (COA) to City Council for deliberation, including a recommendation that City Council consider directing staff to pursue a long-term funding strategy.

Discussion Highlights

The discussion on the solid waste ordinance amendment focused on the inefficiencies of current processes for addressing nuisance vehicles. Staff presented a case file that had been open since 2009, illustrating the delays in the existing system. The proposed definition of a “Nuisance motor vehicle” includes criteria such as the vehicle being more than five years old and having a value of less than $100. Chair Maggie Ullman expressed concern that the $100 value threshold might penalize residents with active projects, such as boats, in their garages. Staff clarified that the ordinance targets infestations, gasoline leaks, and public health hazards rather than aesthetic disputes, and that active projects are not sanitation issues unless they threaten public health. Staff also noted that towing and removal is the final step, occurring only after a $5,000 unpaid citation and a court order.

Regarding the ART Comprehensive Operations Analysis, staff and consultants presented data on the draft transit network. Key figures included 11 average daily riders on the Mayhack route, an annual cost of approximately $125,000 for that route, and a daily travel time of 3 hours and 45 minutes. Staff explained that route adjustments were based on ridership mathematics. Kim Roney asked about the potential for Mayhack to operate its own shuttle service, and staff confirmed that the city had reached out to partners regarding route eliminations. Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, confirmed that the ordinance amendment item is on the agenda briefing for City Council on July 28, 2026.

Community Input

During the public comment period, a representative of the Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC) stated that the MMTC unanimously supported the draft transit network on June 24 and encouraged Council to seek non-fixed route service. Another public commenter expressed support for increasing trips per person, citing a 20-minute frequency threshold for usage increases and arguing that higher ridership mitigates environmental impacts and increases land value. A representative of High Wire Brewing, speaking on behalf of a letter supported by approximately 30 local businesses, urged the city to provide service that benefits more people and to move forward with the plan. Finally, a representative of Sunrise Movement supported the idea of a dedicated funding strategy, mentioning federal funding options for transit-oriented corridors.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to bring the ART Comprehensive Operations Analysis to City Council for deliberation. Additionally, Ben Woody agreed to meet with the committee chair in the coming weeks to determine when a mobile app item for transit payment can be added to the agenda. Kim Roney suggested providing a slide showing the format of nuisance vehicle notices when the ordinance amendment is presented to the full council.

Impact

The ordinance amendment aims to streamline the city’s response to long-standing nuisance vehicle issues on private property, which staff noted can involve complex enforcement steps including cure periods and court orders. The ART Comprehensive Operations Analysis provides a data-driven look at the current transit network, highlighting cost and ridership metrics that will inform City Council’s decisions on future service levels and funding strategies. Both items will proceed to City Council for further deliberation.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches