Skip to main content

Board of Adjustment

July 27, 2026 at 2:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Confrence Room

  • 1 h 14 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

At a glance

  • Approved the 56 Moore Avenue variance 5-0, allowing construction within a reduced aquatic buffer.
  • Denied the 133 S Grove Street rehearing request 5-0, upholding the previous setback determination.

Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: July 27, 2026

The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on July 27, 2026, to address zoning variances and rehearing requests. Chair Suzanne Vernon Godsey opened the session by outlining the board’s quasi-judicial role under North Carolina General Statutes and the City’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). The board first reviewed and adopted the minutes, findings of fact, and conclusions of law from its June 22, 2026 meeting. Following the approval of these records, the board administered oaths to witnesses and proceeded to hear two primary cases: a zoning variance request for 56 Moore Avenue and a rehearing request for 133 S Grove Street.

Key Decisions The board took four formal votes during the meeting. First, a motion to approve the minutes and findings of fact passed 5-0. Second, the board voted 5-0 to print the variance for the 56 Moore Avenue property. Third, a motion to grant standing to a neighboring property owner in the 133 S Grove Street case passed 3-0. Finally, the board voted 5-0 to deny the application for a rehearing regarding the 133 S Grove Street property.

56 Moore Avenue Zoning Variance The board considered a request from applicant Ryan Reynolds to construct a single-family dwelling and parking within an aquatic buffer zone on a 0.17-acre lot zoned RS-8. Staff Planner Madelyn Stone presented the site conditions, noting that the request involves a temporary encroachment of 880 square feet and a permanent encroachment of 720 square feet, reducing the aquatic buffer by an average of 23 feet along the eastern bank. Reynolds explained the site constraints and the need for off-street parking, while also detailing proposed mitigation measures, including a 720-gallon rain catchment tank. Chair Godsey commented on the thoroughness of the application, and a board member moved to print the variance, which the board approved unanimously.

133 S Grove Street Rehearing Request The board addressed a rehearing request filed by Josh Holcomb, a builder representing Blue Ridge Commerce LLC, regarding a dwelling at 133 S Grove Street that encroaches approximately 6 inches into a required 6-foot side setback. Holcomb argued that the house is off by 5-6 inches due to survey marker discrepancies and that negotiations with the neighbor had stalled. Jesse Swords, attorney for the neighboring property owner, Ms. Edwards, moved for her client to be granted standing, which the board approved 3-0. Swords then objected to the rehearing, arguing that the survey data was not "newly discovered" evidence because the facts existed prior to the original May 18, 2026 hearing. Board members, including Billy Bruce Johnson and John Michael Kledis, noted that the evidence could have been produced with reasonable diligence at the last hearing and that the facts had not changed. Consequently, the board denied the rehearing request 5-0.

Follow-ups Staff member Madelyn Stone stated that upon the submission of formal plans to the development portal, she would review them with Nancy Watford and the stormwater department. Additionally, Chair Godsey noted that Nancy Watford would review the gutter downspouts and catchment system for the 56 Moore Avenue property to ensure compliance through the family permitting process. A staff official also indicated they would look into prior variances granted on Moore Avenue.

Impact on Residents These decisions affect property owners in the RS-8 Residential Single-Family High Density District. The approval of the 56 Moore Avenue variance allows for the construction of a dwelling within a reduced aquatic buffer, subject to further stormwater review by city staff. The denial of the 133 S Grove Street rehearing upholds the previous determination regarding the side setback encroachment, maintaining the status quo for the property in question.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches