Historic Resources Commission
August 12, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 30 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: August 12, 2026
The Historic Resources Commission of Asheville & Buncombe County held an in-person meeting on August 12, 2026, at Asheville City Hall. The agenda included the welcome of new commission members Jane Mathews and Richard Mattson, the adoption of previous minutes, and a public hearing regarding a Certificate of Appropriateness application.
Key Decisions The commission voted to approve the minutes and the Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law from the July 12, 2026 meeting. The motion, moved by Ms. Oliva and seconded by Cecil Holt, passed with a vote of 6-0. During the review, a correction was made to the minutes to clarify a previous statement regarding the commission’s responsibility to consider updating design standards. Additionally, the commission unanimously approved the Certificate of Appropriateness for the installation of a four-foot-tall black aluminum picket fence at 29 Elizabeth Street in the Montford Historic District. Staff confirmed that the proposed fence meets the applicable design review standards, including height and opacity limits, and is compatible with the historic character of the neighborhood.
Discussion Highlights Following the formal hearings, the commission discussed several community preservation topics. Jenny Bowen, representing Buncombe County Special Collections, noted that the current month marks the 50th anniversary of the first public art mural in downtown Asheville and suggested the commission consider how aging murals might eventually fall under historic preservation standards. She also raised concerns about the upcoming centennial of significant downtown buildings, including City Hall, and asked if the City had plans for celebrations. Bowen further recommended the Mountaineer Motor Tour’s Douglas Ellington Tour as a resource for the commission. Additionally, Bowen suggested that the commission consider capping meeting times at 8:00 PM to ensure better decision-making, noting that the previous month’s meeting was an outlier in duration. Vice Chair Amy Moxley agreed to communicate this suggestion to the Chair, who has the authority to monitor timing and limit speakers.
Community Input During the public hearing for 29 Elizabeth Street, the property owner spoke regarding the fence’s one-foot setback from the sidewalk. The owner explained that the setback was chosen to protect the roots of a large tree located only five feet from the sidewalk, balancing aesthetic preferences with practical preservation needs.
Follow-ups Jenny Bowen explicitly asked Historic Resources Commission staff to move forward with the process of obtaining a heritage tree designation for the "Historic Treasure Tree" located off Sand Hill and South Bear Creek Road. Deputy City Attorney Jannice Ashley stated that while the City Council has the authority to designate heritage trees via ordinance, a formal process involving permanent easements needs to be created, and indicated that looking into this is a "great first step." Bowen also offered to act as a facilitator to help the church property owners work out the legalities regarding the heritage tree designation.
Impact The approval of the fence at 29 Elizabeth Street allows the property owner to proceed with the installation, provided all necessary permits are obtained. The discussions regarding the "Treasure Tree," estimated to be over 300 years old, highlight ongoing efforts to protect significant local natural landmarks from potential damage by neighboring development. The commission’s consideration of meeting time caps and the review of mural preservation standards reflect an internal focus on improving operational efficiency and expanding the scope of historic preservation resources available to the community.
Meeting Video & Transcript