Historic Resources Commission
September 9, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 2 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: September 9, 2026
The City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission held an in-person meeting on September 9, 2026, to review administrative matters, conduct public hearings on historic preservation projects, and consider a National Register nomination. The meeting began with the announcement that Chair Celesta Gorman had resigned the previous day. Acting Chair Amy Moxley, who was identified as both Commissioner and Vice Chair, assumed the role of chair for the duration of the meeting, noting that this was an unusual situation given her recent appointment.
Key Decisions The commission took the following actions during the meeting:
- Minutes: The commission voted 5-0 to continue the vote to adopt the minutes from the April 28, 2026 Special Work Session, allowing members additional time for review. Separately, the commission voted 5-0 to approve the minutes and Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law from the August 12, 2026 meeting.
- 7 Cherokee Road: The application to reconstruct a damaged retaining wall in the Albemarle Park Historic District was continued to the October 2026 meeting by a unanimous vote (5-0).
- 40 Watauga Street: The application to modify an accessory structure in the Montford Historic District was approved with the condition that revised door specifications be submitted for staff review.
- 3 Angle Street: The application to amend a major work approval for mechanical equipment and entry vestibule changes at a property in the Biltmore Village Historic District was approved unanimously. The certificate was issued with the condition that door hardware be submitted for staff review and approval.
- S.J. Ashworth House: The commission unanimously recommended in favor of the nomination of the S.J. Ashworth House (1733 Charlotte Hwy, Fairview, NC) for the National Register of Historic Places.
Discussion Highlights During the public hearing for 7 Cherokee Road, staff expressed concern that the submitted materials did not match neighborhood aesthetics and noted that the wall must be engineered. The applicant, Julian Montoya, and the property owner’s representative discussed the necessity of tree removal and the alternative of regrading the hill. Staff requested an arborist report, engineering report, updated site plan, and material specifications before the item could be finalized.
For 40 Watauga Street, staff noted that the proposed metal door had not been previously approved for new structures in the district and recommended fiberglass or aluminum. The applicant, Eric Gordon, agreed to change the door material to fiberglass or aluminum and confirmed that the gable end would be shingled to match the existing structure.
Regarding 3 Angle Street, the discussion focused on ADA compliance and screening for new mechanical units. The applicant, representing Beyer Blinder Belle, explained that the units would be elevated on concrete pads with metal platforms and screened by 5-foot tall black metal picket fencing. Commissioners discussed the fence height, noting it exceeded the standard 4-foot limit for side yards, but supported the 5-foot height based on security and life safety concerns. A public commenter commended the architect for retaining the vestibule and requested confirmation that plantings would screen the units from Hendersonville Road. Staff clarified that the property fits the "cottage and mixed use" zoning category rather than commercial.
In the final agenda item, staff presented the S.J. Ashworth House nomination, explaining the commission’s role as a Certified Local Government in making advisory recommendations to the State Historic Preservation Office. The property, built around 1800, was cited under National Register Criterion C for design and construction. Vice Chair Amy Moxley moved to recommend the nomination in favor, which was seconded and passed unanimously.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to review and approve the submitted door hardware for 3 Angle Street. For 7 Cherokee Road, the applicant is required to submit an arborist report, engineering report, updated site plan, and material specifications by the next submittal deadline of September 23, 2026, ahead of the October 2026 meeting. Staff also noted that the commission’s recommendation for the S.J. Ashworth House will be sent to the State Historic Preservation Office.
Impact These decisions affect the preservation of historic architecture in Asheville’s designated historic districts. The approval of modifications at 40 Watauga Street and 3 Angle Street allows for necessary updates to these properties while ensuring they remain consistent with historic character standards. The continuation of the 7 Cherokee Road project ensures that engineering and aesthetic concerns are fully addressed before construction begins. The recommendation for the S.J. Ashworth House may provide the property owner with access to historic rehabilitation tax credits and other benefits associated with National Register listing.
Meeting Video & Transcript