Rescheduled: Historic Resources Commission
November 18, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 2 h 31 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
The Historic Resources Commission of the City of Asheville held an in-person meeting on November 18, 2026, to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness and address commission governance. The session began with the adoption of the minutes and findings of fact from the October 14, 2026 meeting, which passed without recorded corrections. The commission also administered oaths to new witnesses and staff members, including Tracy Wyman, a Parks and Recreation Project Manager, who provided testimony regarding a project in the Montford Historic District.
The commission took action on several development applications. For 7 Cherokee Road in the Albemarle Park Historic District, the commission unanimously approved the Certificate of Appropriateness for the reconstruction of a damaged retaining wall. The approval included conditions requiring the submission of the stone type, source, and a landscaping plan for staff review. Similarly, the commission unanimously approved the application for 14 Lodge Street in the Biltmore Village Historic District, which involves replacing a fabric awning and signage and installing outdoor dining furniture. For 345 Montford Avenue in the Montford Historic District, the commission unanimously approved an amendment to a previous Certificate of Appropriateness to replace a damaged stone wall with a new stone veneer wall, with a condition that Parks and Recreation staff confirm with HRC staff if the alternative method is needed before field work begins.
Two applications were not fully resolved during the meeting. The commission voted unanimously to continue the consideration of the application for 32 Hendersonville Road, which proposes a painted mural, to the December meeting. For 121 Pearson Drive, a motion was made to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for a two-story addition, but no second or vote was recorded before the meeting segment ended.
The most significant discussion of the evening concerned the application for 37 Rosewood Avenue in the Montford Historic District, which proposes a new 1,220-square-foot addition. Staff and commissioners raised substantial concerns that the proposed addition is disproportionately large compared to the existing historic structure, with one commissioner noting it is 85% larger than the original house and "eats the lot alive." Staff emphasized that the addition must be subordinate to the existing home and significantly smaller. Despite these concerns, the commission unanimously voted to grant a Certificate of Appropriateness with conditions requiring revised specifications for windows, doors, mechanical units, and roofing, as well as a tree protection plan. Immediately following this vote, the commission unanimously voted to continue the consideration of the application to the January meeting at the applicant’s motion, allowing for further design revisions.
A substantial portion of the meeting was dedicated to a debate regarding the commission’s internal governance, specifically the appointment of members to the Executive Committee. Several commissioners expressed frustration that the current process lacks transparency and limits the ability of regular members to influence policy or propose amendments to design guidelines. One commissioner argued that the Executive Committee holds disproportionate power over the commission's agenda and policy direction. In response, city staff explained that the Executive Committee had worked on the relevant issues for two years prior to the current membership changes and that legal advice had been provided regarding the amendment process. The Chair acknowledged the request to move forward with a more open process.
In follow-up actions, city staff agreed to review questions regarding whether a vote is required for the chair position and whether the chair has the authority to make appointments to the Executive Committee based on the rules of procedure. The commission’s next meeting is scheduled for December 9, 2026.
Meeting Video & Transcript